PhantomMullet's profile

Welcoming feedback and/or critique on any reviews I've written on this site.

I sometimes revise my reviews if I feel they read a bit sloppy, have too many grammatical errors, or I see certain albums in a new light.

I don't really have a hard criteria for scores - a 75% on one album could have a very different meaning from the same score on a different band's album. As much as I try to be consistent, I try to look at things more holistically. Did the band have a crappy start, but improve? Later albums will likely reflect a more positive score. Conversely, bands of years with consistently good output may have a lower score if they later release an album that is of poor quality. Needless to say, I may be tweaking the scores of some old reviews to still maintain more consistency with my own internal system.

But as before, I'm always looking for feedback.