Register Forgot login?

© 2002-2017
Encyclopaedia Metallum

Best viewed
without Internet Explorer,
in 1280 x 960 resolution
or higher.

Black Waters - 96%

trollhammer666, December 19th, 2013

Scimitar’s full-length album Black Waters is an instant classic born of mythical and melodic passages while spreading tales of pillaging, plundering and bloody pagan naval warfare. There is only one album that has ever given me the addictive shivers that Black Waters instills in me: Into Eternity’s legendary icon Buried in Oblivion – which a lot consider to be easily one of the greatest metal masterpieces of the last decade.

Black Waters is the perfect storm of flowing and thundering drum passages, seemingly endless and deeply hypnotic guitar melodies and everything else but the kitchen sink. There is a perfect combination of razor-sharp death growls and ‘rolling on the waves’ calm vocals. I really wish my ears could tolerate this beast of an album on an inhumane sound level. Scimitar’s pristine musical solution will course through your body leaving you wanting to do nothing more but exceed your iPod’s volume limitations.

The album kicks off with a gripping instrumental introduction that sets the mood of the album perfectly: a combination of gentle hums, soft acoustic and cackling thunder in the background. A heart-racing lead guitar and drum pattern form an unstoppable climax right before tying into the second track “Brethren Of The Coast”. The only tear I shed over this album is for the intensity leading into this song. Unfortunately the ridiculous build-up in the end of the first track is quickly squelched as the second track plays much quieter but does easily make up for it with a truly breathtaking riff.

Undeniably my favourite element of Black Waters is the lyrical content. These stories of pure ruthlessness sound destined when chanted over the anesthesizing flowing melodies; it is easy to get distracted by the upliftingly vicious musicianship that comes with it though. There are two songs, "Forest Of Wolves", and "Habeas Corpus", that do not fit the frequently used “watery grave” theme. However, it feels as if they were prophesied to belong in the respective track listing, telling side-fables of other merciless combating scenarios.

Without question my favourite song is “Buried At Sea”. The first minute alone is host to some of the most exquisite, effortless sounding and truly breathtaking transitions ever. The chorus – which shows the gentler and ultra-calm “soft side” of the song though there is the occasional bitter growl during, is in direct contrast with the sheer speed and harshness of the speedy melodies and shrieking growls during the all-out metal passages. The salient harshness each time they belt out “Buried At Sea” a different way makes me want to scream along until my lungs combust.

The majority of the album, ("Mariner’s Lament", "Brethren Of The Coast", "Buried at Sea", "Fireship" and the album title itself), really brings out a “pirate metal” theme. Most people guffaw at the sound of such a novelty genre but do not take Black Waters lightly: Scimitar’s innovation rips the laughable stereotype apart by fusing the novelty genre with their own chiseled, razor-sharp melodic death metal vocals and ditching all simplicities by bringing in their own fluidized entrancing melodies.

The album is of average length, though there are only 5 full songs to be found. Fortunately this is nothing to complain about except for the fact that you will be kicking and screaming for more by the time the final hasty verse of “Fireship” is done. What I would, (and have for the last year or so), consider the top metal prospect of Canada, Scimitar, keep doing what you’re doing because greatness is on its way.

written for

Fire It Up - 80%

Basilisk, November 30th, 2012

Scimitar have been dancing in the corner of my eye for some time now, but for some reason I was slow to give them my full attention. I should have realized my folly... Scimitar shouldn’t be ignored. “Black Waters,” their first full-length album, reveals a slab of potential that we can start crackin our teeth on. The album sets sail with an instrumental (Mariner’s Lament) that made me think: yeah that’s classy. When ‘Brethren of the Coast’ fires up you get a sense of what you’re in for: adventures in technical guitar, rollicking harsh vocals, smooth backing vocals, relentless drums, and a touch of keys. The bass runs high and dry, a tone I’d compare to the one Steve Harris uses (Iron Maiden). I loved the visit from the acoustic guitar in the song ‘Forest of Wolves.’ The clean vocals, which are in the style of Forefather, make themselves welcome in pretty much every track.

I’m a fan of solos with melody and Scimitar’s guitarists share a good dynamic in this regard, definitely some technical bones in their fingers. The guitar tones remind me of the legendary Mithotyn, a melodic black metal band whose guitaring could’ve fit into the power metal genre had it not been for the harsh vocals involved. Scimitar’s main purveyor of harsh vocals fits right in with a black/death metal vibe. His lyrics are solid too, though perhaps they could’ve used a few less words to say what they needed to. The lyrics have a pirate motif- pirates are an engaging subject, though I hope Scimitar doesn’t go the direction of Alestorm, a band that is heavy on pirates and light on substance. Yet Running Wild has both pirates and substance, so it can be done. I’m eager to see how Scimitar will spice it up in the future.

Scimitar’s songs are quite hefty in length, which is admirable, but methinks some of them could have benefitted from being condensed a tad. The main offender is the grand finale ‘Fireship.’ If I’m going home with an eleven-minute song, it’s either going to be engaging or it’s going to slip me a roofy. I'd like it to be focused enough to explore its own dimensions rather than succumb to self-indulgence. Scimitar walk a fine line here with this track in particular. I thought it could’ve easily been half the length at no cost to its quality (lose a couple verses and bars of guitar wankery and definitely get rid of the “hey-hey-heys” which should only be done live and never written into songs). My favourite track, however, is ‘Buried at Sea,’ an engaging nine-minutes. So all in all this album shows that Scimitar has the power.

I compared Scimitar to Forefather and Mithotyn, two top-notch bands. Ensiferum, Suidakra, and Insomium also come to mind. These are all remarkable bands. Scimitar aren’t at that level yet, they’re just starting out. They aren’t doing anything totally original, but you can tell they’re enjoying themselves and their music. With a little focus and refining Scimitar could be cutting a path to prominence in no time.

Alestorm and Ensiferum had a baby! - 91%

PimpDaddyMcNasty, October 24th, 2010

Scimitar's two-song demo was a decent piece of melodic pirate/folk metal - gruff vocals, rollicking drums, melodic leads and nearly progressive song structures. With this, their first full-length album, Scimitar step up the formula yet again, utilizing better production and throwing in a bit more technicality and pirate feel to create one hell of a good album.

Both tracks on the demo are here; "Brethren Of The Coast" and "Habeas Corpus" and they've never sounded better. The musicians have clearly improved since the demo, and it shows in the reworking of these two tracks. There are four new tracks here as well, including a mellow, folky instrumental that helps set the tone for the rest of the album. "Forest Of Wolves" is a fast, folky romp that even finds a way to be, dare I say it, catchy. "Buried At Sea" begins as a fast, melody-driven episode that grinds to a slow burn with the addition of some clean vocals and a nicely placed, speedy solo about 3 minutes in.

The album concludes with the 11+ minute epic "Fireship." This track has everything; the melodic pirate metal sections, galloping double bass, even some subtle keyboard. About six minutes in, a blazing guitar solo burns through the track, and at nine minutes, everything erupts into chaos as the drums blast away, the vocals shout at the speed of machine gun fire, and sounds of fire begin to be heard, ushering in another blazing solo which culminates the album.

Scimitar have struck folk metal gold with this album, evoking Alestorm if they had more balls, or Ensiferum if they sailed under the Jolly Roger. The constant melodic leads can become slightly monotonous at times, and the vocals can become a bit repetitive, but these minor deficiencies are vastly overshadowed by the positive qualities of the album. An excellent work by a rising star.