Register Forgot login?

© 2002-2021
Encyclopaedia Metallum

Best viewed
without Internet Explorer,
in 1280 x 960 resolution
or higher.

Privacy Policy

The Book of Lunn (Chapter 4: Later That Night...) - 58%

Dying_Hope, July 13th, 2020
Written based on this version: 2009, CD, Lundr Records (Limited edition, CD-R)


Immediately after I finished my last Panopticon review "The Book of Lunn (Chapter 3: The Master and the Apprentice)", I wanted to write the next chapter for this series and dive into the next full-length album "Collapse". Well, happy too early, because just before I wanted to start I noticed that there was another split album between me and "Collapse". It's always like that with splits: Some songs of 2, 3 or 4 bands are put on the same album and this can be confusing. Because in most cases the bands are musically very different even if they come from the same genre. This usually gives the impression of a compilation that you got in every heavy metal magazine for free. It may of course be that new bands are discovered for you, but most of the material contained on splits are usually not one of the best works of a band. However, exceptions confirm the rule!

To be fair, there may be splits that captivates you immediately, and I've heard of a handful of great Panopticon splits. But most of the splits I've heard from different bands so far are mostly b-sides, live versions, remix songs or something else. This does not mean that they are bad, but in most cases there is a loss of quality compared to a full album. But let's not talk around the bush, let's get to the basics.

White Light Rains on Haymarket Square

Let's start with Wheels Within Wheels before we get to Panopticon. "Beginning" starts with a melodious and dreamy melody that cries longingly. This melancholic melody runs through the whole song, which seems more like an intro to me. Due to the low-fi production, the drums unfortunately take a back seat. Too bad because a little more pressure would have done the effect really well. The guitar stops and turns into noise between 3:48 and 4 minutes. It definitely has a nice hypnotic effect on me even if I am not completely carried away by the built-up mood.

"White Light Rains Down on ..." looked really cool at first. It builds on a very melodic riff that varies a little from time to time. The medium-fast drumming gives the entire first section of the song a yearning note. A sample starts at the 5-minute mark and the song becomes more melancholic and dissonant. A screeching sound is heard and from this point the song got on my nerves completely, although it still felt wistful and sad. So far there has been no singing, and the screeching melody kept coming back until the song went into total noise. After ten minutes a lonely guitar sings its requiem. At this point I realized that the song was over and I was disappointed because the euphoria I felt at the beginning turned into an absolute pain. Unfortunately, the potential was completely wasted. The way I see it, Wheels Within Wheels are really not my thing. I would not deny their talent because I may just not understand their music.

Panopticon also does not add any groundbreaking but really successful material to their discography. "...Speaking..." is an absolute highlight in the acoustic version. It sounds like a completely new song, but the practiced ear recognizes that it is actually "...Speaking..." that has been rearranged here. This ten minute atmospheric piece is slow and mostly relies on haunting dark americana vibes. "The Ghosts of Haymarket Square" shows Panopticon in a more raw black metal phase with great melodies in the middle of the song. There's a lot of darkness inside this tunes, it feels very earthy but nonetheless quite raw. The low-fi production fits the atmosphere very well, I am blown away. 


Somehow it is paradoxical that I can only write a small paragraph about Panopticon but two paragraphs for Wheels Within Wheels. This may be because I find nothing to complain about the Panopticon songs, but Wheels Within Wheels is absolutely not my case. If only "...Speaking..." and "The Ghosts of Haymarket Square" were included then (again) a close 90% would have come out, but with the Wheels Within Wheels songs it is unfortunately only 58%.