Register Forgot login?

© 2002-2017
Encyclopaedia Metallum

Best viewed
without Internet Explorer,
in 1280 x 960 resolution
or higher.

Did a robot make this compilation? - 43%

SpyreWorks, February 23rd, 2010

...because that's what this seems like. Although having the most famous and most fun Iron Maiden songs on here, the compilation adheres to a strict "2 songs per album" rule, which is ultimately the downfall of the compilation and the reason it's a piece of shit. It's as if a computer program picked the two most famous songs from each album then put them together, and this wouldn't really be a problem, except for the fact that the title of this album is "The Essential Iron Maiden", not "A Taste of Maiden" or something like that. Most of the songs on this compilation aren't essential by a long stretch. The essential Iron Maiden stuff was from the beginning of their long career, and the problem is that great songs such as "Hallowed Be Thy Name", "Rime of the Ancient Mariner", "Powerslave", "22 Acacia Avenue", "Children of the Damned" and more are all deprived of spaces in the compilation while globs of shit that no one cares about occupy them. One other thing that irks me is that two classic songs "Running Free" and "Iron Maiden" are live versions. Why!? The original studio versions are a lot better and fit much better into a compilation!

Despite all that though, this is still an Iron Maiden release, and the songs are of course, quite awesome regardless. Loud and epic singing, melodic guitar harmonies, powerful and tight drumming and great bass work. The worst parts on the compilation are the Blaze Bayley-era songs. "Futureal" is pretty bad, "Sign of the Cross" is infinitely boring and "Man On the Edge" is painful to listen to (you can tell how hard Blaze is trying to be Bruce, and he fails at it so badly that you have to pity him). The only good Blaze song is "The Clansman", which is a calm epic. The best songs are undoubtedly the earlier ones, from pre-1990s Iron Maiden. "Run to the Hills", "The Trooper" and more are all great and famous songs, but as I said before, SO MANY AMAZING SONGS ARE MISSING.

If the creators of the compilation had put a little thought into compiling songs, then classic and truly essential songs would liberate their spots from the bland and unwanted musical turds of more recent years. Despite all this, it's still a good listen if this is your first Iron Maiden purchase or if you just want to see what all the fuss is about, and in the end, it's still Iron Maiden, none of the songs are THAT bad. But this is a compilation, not an album, and I'm reviewing the selection of songs and how they fit with the title, and my official conclusion is that this compilation sucks.

Decent Compilation, But Lacking A LOT Of Material - 62%

NecroWraith, July 19th, 2007

Iron Maiden have always been one of my favorite bands of all time. However, I would HIGHLY recommend getting their full discography [perhaps excluding the Blaze releases] instead of a Best-Of album. 62 points? Quite low for a Maiden album? Let me explain...

First of all, let me start off by saying every song on this album is great. That's not an issue. However, it is clear to see that the track on this album were selected in only one way: the two highest-ranking singles from each of their albums. Of course, a LOT is missing....

Here is just a short list of songs that I realized were not on the album, just at a short glance. I'm sure there are millions more:

Murders Of The Rue Morgue
Can I Play With Madness
Rime Of The Ancient Mariner
Dream Of Mirrors
The Loneliness Of The Long Distance Runner
Stranger In A Strange Land

and most importantly, my FAVORITE Maiden song of all time....


So why the low score? As I said, this compilation is decent, but only features two songs off of each CD, guaranteeing that a huge number of classic tunes are lost. If you want to start off listening to Maiden, get Number Of The Beast or Killers. Hell, get their full discography. Because if you stick merely to this compilation, you won't know the true metal legends that are Maiden.

-Marcin C.