Register Forgot login?

© 2002-2017
Encyclopaedia Metallum

Best viewed
without Internet Explorer,
in 1280 x 960 resolution
or higher.

They've done better - 70%

calderabanuet, August 2nd, 2013

So, a new release by these Netherlanders, uh? Are you ready to hate? I said, ARE YOU READY TO HAAATE? Yes? Well, I don’t. Let me state this plainly: I’ve followed these guys’ career since the very beginning, back in the good ol’days of “The Phantom Agony” and shit, and once and again I’ve enjoyed their music, at least a little in some cases. I’ll be as fair as you can get when judging this beast though, but don’t you expect me to encourage your killer instincts against’em.

I must admit I had little expectations when getting this one, as their last two full length albums were… let’s just say they’re not my favorite, yet, when listening to “RFTI”, I gladly realized there are a few new elements to check out. Perhaps quite a few.

The use of choirs is the vastest and richest that I can recall since “The Works” in “We Will Take You With Us”, and I even could recognize a couple voices from back then. Not quite innovative, but effective. Also, metal parts in the songs (meaning the riffs within these symphonic compositions) are more metal than ever; I’d go as far as saying there are some death metal passages, even though they take only a few seconds. Is it that ol’Mark is being strengthened by working in Mayan?

What I really found new, so to speak, is some HINTS of what you could call progressive stuff; meaning an occasional technical guitar riff, and solos! Yes, Epica have never been known for their killer guitar soloing, nevertheless there are a couple fine attempts here. ‘Twas about time!

Now about Simone… her vocals remain pretty much the same. I mean she’s good, that’s undeniable, and furthermore, she’s been improving her singing indeed; the thing is she’s been getting better and better as an exquisite opera singer, if you like, not as a metal one. The result, just too pretty.

And that’s nothing new; something that has always kept me not-that-much-into symphonic gothic bands, and it particularly happens with Jansen and company, is that sort of luminosity they convey not with lyrics maybe, but with their music itself. It feels as though they said “there’s still hope” or “sunshine is coming”; CRAP! That’s exactly the reason why I was so happy when Tarja was finally kicked out of Nightwish, and would stop so proficiently destroying ANY metal effect those guys could have on me.

No, for the world, NO, I’m not even suggesting Simone should or could be expelled from the band. I’d rather have her performing a lil’more aggressive and less fine vocals. That was one of the few highlights “The Divine Conspiracy” had, if you know what I mean.

Summarizing, “Requiem for the Indifferent” displays a few new features, but is still another standard release by Epica; not bad, interesting, TOO pretty, pretentious, well accomplished, etc. I honestly hope this is some sort of a transition work that’ll lead to a new sound. If you liked any of their previous albums, you’d enjoy this one; if you didn’t, why bother?

—Originally written for

Epica's best album yet! - 99%

Bruce500, October 12th, 2012

I used to be an intense Epica fan awhile ago, but had gotten bored of them after I started expanding my tastes in music to more extreme forms of metal. When they announced the name of this album, I was expecting some stereotypical "make love, not war" album, and was expecting to be disappointed. However, when I bought the album after the release, I was very surprised at how much an already great band had improved their sound!

As you probably already know, Epica is mostly known for its symphonic elements and operatic clean vocals. Most people automatically label them as a power metal band because of this, because they hear mezzo-soprano singing and think Nightwish. Epica is not just a power metal band, however, and this album proves it. You can hear all sorts of elements in this album, from Beethoven to Bach, Opeth to Death, Sonata Arctica to Blind Guardian. It's not often that you find a band that successfully forges its own style out of many styles, and even less often that you hear it done right. Epica's mix of mainly progressive metal with some death, power, and classical music thrown in is a combination that works a lot better that it sounds like it would.

The album starts off with a symphonic track called "Karma", which opens to "Monopoly on Truth". When the end of Karma faded into Monopoly on Truth, my ears almost exploded. The song (and entire album) takes Epica's sound and turns it into something more. This album at this point is already pushing Epica in a more aggressive direction than ever before while keeping the complex songwriting that Epica is known for. My favorite part of this album is the crisp guitar tone. In their previous albums, which were still great, the guitars were sometimes completely drowned out by synths and drums. They finally improved this in Design Your Universe and perfected it in Requiem for the Indifferent.

Heaviness aside, Requiem for the Indifferent has a lot of beautiful symphonic elements to it. The song "Delirium" is one of the most beautiful pieces I've ever heard from any musician, showing that Epica is much more than just a metal band. "Anima" reminds me of the Dimmu Borgir song "Det nye riket" with its dark sounding piano.

Of course, I can't tell you how great this album is through a review, so you're just going to have to go buy it! I highly recommend it!

Great Album - 100%

ayham qasim, June 16th, 2012

When I heard that Epica was going to be releasing a new album, the ultimate excitement I felt at that moment is indescribable. Epica is another one of those bands where each album is better than the one before, just like Soilwork, After Forever, DevilDriver, All Shall Perish, Katatonia, and Eternal Tears of Sorrow. Although not the most commercially successful, Epica has proved themselves to me (and millions of other people) that they are truly one of the (if not THE) most talented and creative symphonic metal bands of all-time. But even though that’s just a matter of opinion, anyone who is into the female-fronted symphonic metal scene can easily say that Epica holds an incredible amount of talented musicianship. In the symphonic metal area, the most BITCHED ABOUT topic is definitely who is the best singer. Some of the singers that would definitely be nominees in my book would be Tarja Turunen, Floor Jansen, and Anette Olzon. But honestly, none of them even come close to matching the paralyzing voice of Simone Simons (I’m just saying that to put my opinion out there, I’m not a music elitist). I have always loved Design Your Universe, and on December 2nd of 2010, I was convinced that Epica couldn’t POSSIBLY get ANY better when I saw them perform live with Scar Symmetry, Blackguard, and The Agonist.

Requiem for the Indifferent butchered that thought. I’m not exaggerating at all; Epica actually got better. But the sound of Requiem for the Indifferent is far from being similar to the sound of Design Your Universe. This new album made me realize that Design Your Universe is actually one of their softer albums. The reason why is because Requiem for the Indifferent takes a huge step in the death metal direction; that’s right folks, DEATH METAL! But, like every other Epica album, Requiem for the Indifferent has its fair share of ballads that cause people (including me) to shed tears with its sheer beauty and immensely powerful emotion. The song that originally got me officially HOOKED on Epica was Tides of Time (still one of my ALL-TIME favorite songs). Epica failed to disappoint me with their slightly gospel-influenced ballad, Delirium. I’m pretty sure a lot of you are asking, WHERES THE HEAVY SHIT??

The answer to that question lies in the first two tracks. These tracks are very similar to the first two tracks on The Divine Conspiracy. By that, I mean that it has the soft intro track filled with complex choir chords that suck you in like a black hole into a FAST and FUCKING HEAVY track. The only difference is that the heavy track on Requiem for the Indifferent is FAR, FAR heavier than the one off The Design Conspiracy. After the second song, you’re met with the ballad I was talking about earlier. After that, Internal Warfare relentlessly pounds you into the dirt; listening to the song should be enough to prove that statement. I guess the majority of the album’s material is made up of these merciless and heavy songs that Epica has been known to only use sparingly…until now.

Honestly, the musicians haven’t gotten any better. The reason why is because they pretty much reached capacity almost four years ago!! But that never means that it’s impossible to even further push the limits. The guitarist that also does the growls (Epica refers to them as “grunts”) and some mediocre screams improved his vocals a lot since the previous album. His growls don’t sound as weak and…I don’t know…there’s something about his growls in the previous albums…something about them that’s missing or lacking something…I’ve just never been able to put my finger on it. But whatever his vocals were lacking before was fixed; he could easily be a good fit for the next big melodic death band. And on top of that, his screams are A LOT better than before. Also, of course, Simone’s singing voice continues to go uphill while showing no signs of slowing down EVER.

This is definitely Epica’s best album without a doubt. But remember, this is the heaviest record they’ve ever put out, so it’s hard to ultimately compare it to their other material due to the near-dramatic change in overall musical style they’ve taken. When I listen to this record, I shake my head in disbelief that they actually created a record better than Design Your Universe. This is an INSTANT classic and shouldn’t be missed by anyone, symphonic metal fan or not. I would give this a perfect score on any scale. 5/5, 10/10, 20/20, 100/100, 100%, A+, whatever scale you would prefer to use (I usually go out of 20), I guarantee you that I will give it full credit. I’m so glad that I pre-ordered this CD (which came with a shirt).