Register Forgot login?

© 2002-2017
Encyclopaedia Metallum

Best viewed
without Internet Explorer,
in 1280 x 960 resolution
or higher.

Why? - 30%

TheNecromancer, February 6th, 2012

With My Dying Bride doing remakes of their older material, it only makes sense that another death-doom pioneer would want to do the same at vaguely the same time. Though Anathema are largely under-appreciated when compared to their contemporaries at the time (Namely My Dying Bride and Paradise Lost), Anathema released some of the finest death-doom of their time with excellent releases such as A Silent Enigma and Pentecost III. Their earlier albums, where not quite as good as those, were definitely worth a listen to. Now in their atmospheric rock days, Anathema have decided to take these compositions into an orchestral context into a cooler and perhaps more pleasant shade. These old, crushing songs have turned into relaxing orchestral, cool and pleasant mini-ballads. Sounds nice, right? Anathema have already proven they're good at taking their old material and turning it into a new shade, with the excellent Hindsight. But Anathema totally ruin the potential of this from the offset.

Unlike Evinta by My Dying Bride, and even Hindsight, Anathema don't really re-write the songs in any meaningful way. They only steal their old melodies and repeat them over and over, rinse-repeat. Part of what made some of their doom metal songs so good is how they were structured, and that is totally and utterly gone in Falling Deeper. Take Kingdom for example, one of Anathema's finest tracks of that era, all they do is take the simplest riff of that song and play it on a piano to some soft ambience for 4 minutes, missing out on some of the best riffs and melodies of the original along with the lyrics and structure that made the song so gripping. The remake of J'ai Fait Une Promesse is just totally pointless, the song was already a near-orchestral song and all they did here was make it sound softer and nearly double the length of it. They do it again on another track, Alone. Where this one is better than J'ai Fait Une Promesse, it just doesn't add anything to the original track. The doom metal tracks should have been the songs focussed on but they were pretty much thrown onto the backburner in favour of interludes that didn't need to be made any softer.

They attempt expanding one or two tracks, Sunset of Age for example but placed right at the end of the album it's too little too late. If they added to these songs in meaningful ways like Hindsight this could have been great, the soft and cool orchestral arrangements coupled with the ringing e-bow like feedback and the soft vocal interplay really does sound pleasant but it ends there. It takes meaningful, massive songs and turns them into trite ear-pleasing near-ambient. It's just not good enough when this band are capable of so much more.

Fans of their doom metal past will probably want to avoid this, but those who are unfamiliar with their doom metal material might get some enjoyment out of this if you don't look for anything meaningful. They could have done so much with this concept but they just didn't, and it just makes me ask why the hell they even bothered.