true_death wrote:
What I really like is, where "Redeemer of Souls" felt like an attempt to revisit different sounds & styles that Priest has had over the decades - maybe a little "self congratulatory" if you want to see it that way, this one is very consistent in style and seems to have a lot more character and personality as it's own album. It also feels surprisingly youthful and energetic...Rob in particular sounds amazing here, obviously he can't do the screams as well as he once could, but he more than makes up for that in the sheer passion and conviction of his voice.
You mean that seemingly routine lyric in the second verse of Lightning Strike where Rob struggles and sounds incredibly forced and out of key?
true_death wrote:
Anyway, in my book, this is easily the best thing Priest has done since "Painkiller", though I suppose many will argue that it isn't really saying a lot
.
How? That would be insulting since they have released five good to great albums, two of which are almost classics (Jugulator & Nostradamus) since the lone time in their career where they tried to be consistent. (Painkiller)
- Worshiping Painkiller demonstrates a lack of appreciation for what Judas Priest had always stood for. Judas Priest are the definition of inconsistent. No two consecutive albums have sounded the same and they never maintained any kind of style/theme/speed on any album. A good example? Take Sin After Sin:
Opens with an epic Power Metal anthem (
Sinner), which is followed by (
Diamonds & Rust) a cover of a ..... Folk song? A song that pretty much gave Iron Maiden the identity they would abuse for over 30 years. (
Starbreaker) is next and that song is just a distorted guitar away from being a Jehtro Tull reject. Followed by an all out ballad (The ONLY time this happened until Lost Love on Nostradamus 31 years and 13 albums later) complete with Jazz guitar lines and percussion and one of the most emotional vocal passages of Rob's life with (
Last Rose Of Summer). (
Let Us Prey) is .................. Gospel! That is right, despite having no energy whatsoever since the first song, Priest greets their listeners with a song that literally begins with a Church Organ. Then it segues directly into a song (
Call For the Priest) that is probably the first ever true Speed Metal track and combines said Speed Metal with Gospel. (
Raw Deal) has thrash riffage during the final section and the first half of (
Here Comes the Tears) sounds like an Eddie Money rejection before the album ends with what very well may be the first ever true Thrash Metal song (
Dissident Aggressor)!
How is that for consistency? Judas Priest built their entire legacy on being eclectic and not making every song on the album sound the same. Each album has that one song that sounds like a completely different band than the rest.
MawBTS wrote:
After listening to the whole thing I'll go even further: this is the one of the best albums Priest has ever done.
I don't know, maybe it is just having grown up with Priest but I cannot fathom how one could have every Priest recording at the tip of their fingers and find this is on par with Killing Machine, Sin After Sin, Turbo, Defenders or Jugulator. Or hell, even Nostradamus.
MawBTS wrote:
If I had to rank their albums I'd go Painkiller/Stained/Defenders/Sad Wings/Screaming, and then a tie between this and Killing Machine (after that there would be British/Sin/Ram then whatever's left).
I must be the oddest Judas Priest fan there is, except for when I remember how many fans before the internet loved the albums everyone on the net seems to hate. Since the albums can be ranked, for me, it would go:
- Unleashed In the East: (Single greatest Metal album ever recorded. Sorry. The final Running Wild scream followed by that epic guitar breakdown is when I officially became a fan of the band. Also, how can one NOT just adore how Rob sings, "VICTIM OF CHANGES!" or his blood chilling screams at that intense as fuck outro to Genocide? Or how ruthlessly brutal Ian Hill is throughout but at the end of Tyrant.)
- British Steel: (Contains my all-time favorite Priest song: Steeler)
- Killing Machine: (Love all the elements of Funk/Folk/Motown. This masterpiece is seductively groovy)
- Turbo: (I adore just how fun and carefree this album is. Takes me back to 1986 and how exciting an adventure it was to see a Judas Priest show. Contains my all-time second favorite Priest song: Reckless)
- Jugulator: (Tim Owens is a beast and in the lower register is a superior vocalist to Halford. Songs like Bullet Train, Brain Dead, Blood Stained, Death Row, Dead Meat are ALL wicked awesome. Cathedral Spires is such a masterpiece and only Decapitate and Abductors bring the album down from a legendary status. Judas Priest lost one of the greatest vocalists to ever live and somehow found a man who was able to fill in his shoes but fit snug in with the band as if he had always been there.)
- Sin After Sin: (An eclectic Metal masterpiece. A testament of how Metal should be: VERSATILE!)
- Defenders Of the Faith: (This has to be the fastest 80's Priest album.)
- '98 Live Meltdown: (That is right, another Owens album. There is no way one is being honest if they hear the amazing renditions of all the Jugulator songs but also The Ripper, A Touch Of Evil, Metal Gods, Diamonds & Rust & Night Crawler and say Tim does not deserve respect. However, nothing Priest ever did of their classic material slays as much as this live rendition of Rapid Fire. [Read Below])
- Stained Class: (This album is more hype than anything else.)
- Point Of Entry: (Not sure why so many dislike it. Because it is Priest-Lite? So what? Metal does not always have to be over the top. There is a thing that even the earliest metallers understood: It is good to utilize subtlety and quieter moments to emphasize the heavier parts. There ARE some duds though as Don't Go and All The Way are bad with the former being one of the most embarrassing moments in the bands career. Troubleshooter, On The Run, Turning Circles & Desert Plains are all amazing though.)
- Sad Wings Of Destiny: (The start of true Heavy Metal but holy shit is that production job dated. The one thing that, while nice for educational purposes, brings the material down.)
- Screaming For Vengeance: (First 4 songs rule with authority, rest of album sucks a big hard one)
- Demolition: (This could honestly be higher since In Between, Bloodsuckers, Cyberface are all awesome and Subterfuge is a flipping masterpiece. Something about this album does not work as well as Jugulator though. It is still better than everything released since Halford rejoined the band.)
- Nostradamus: (Dawn Of Creation, Death, Lost Love, Persecution, Solitude, Exiled, Alone, Calm Before the Storm, Nostradamus & Future Of Mankind are ALL awesome songs. I also appreciate it how much branching out Priest was doing here. Adding yet ANOTHER style of Metal under their belt, how many does that make now? It would probably be easier to identity which subgenres of Metal has Judas Priest not sampled or even created at this point. This album proves that Priest are without peer.)
- Painkiller: (PRIESTKILLER! The title track & All Guns Blazing are amazing songs, the rest is just good. Overhyped beyond belief.)
- Ram It Down: (While the tour for this album was great when I caught it, the album is almost too mechanical and less diverse. A sign of what was too come with the following album.)
- Angel Of Retribution: (Boring comeback and immediate knowledge that this incarnation was not your parents Judas Priest. Instead of sticking it out with Owens, the band decided to, for at least 1 album, to rest on their laurels and be self-congratulatory.)
- Redeemer Of Souls: (Production is bad but Richie gives the band some energy. Overall however, this album is rather boring, way too much filler. Crossfire, Dragonaut and Halls Of Valhalla are all great though.)
- Firepower: (Jury still out on this one)
- Rocka Rolla: (Does anything else BUT this deserve to be last on the list? Run Of The Mill is an early masterstroke. Oh damn those ending vocals, that extremely emotional opening guitar solo by Glenn and the psychedelic solo by Ken. I wish the band had done this live past the Sad Wings tour. The entire rest of the album sucks, especially Never Satisfied, the single worst song on Judas Priest's career. How many riffs does this song have? I think it is just 1)
I saw Priest live with Tim Owens five times. 2 times on the Jugulator tour and 3 times on the Demolition tour. The first was in the Avalon Ballroom in Boston and when they did Rapid Fire, about four songs in, I was stunned. I had obviously already heard Jugulator so I knew Tim was great but I can still remember the exact moment I was sold on him being the man for the job. The added bridge after the second verse, the "Rapid Fire! Between the Eyes!" part, most of the audience was more stunned than anything else. Most I saw kinda stopped and listened, a little confused, and not even really in the mosh pit. That can be a disaster for such a Speed Metal classic but I think one of the reasons it worked is the part only lasts for ten seconds before Tim screamed the words Rapid Fire. The way he screamed them and then held the note for another ten seconds was godly and he stood kind of like a stone while everyone, including me, yelled back our approval. He soaked it up while the band does that simple thrashy riff that builds to the amazing bridge and, to be honest, instead of moshing, most of the people I could see was more floored by how high Tim's voice got than the song itself. He made that part his own and most of the crowd seemed shocked by how much he sounded like Rob but that final scream of the song capped it all off. It was a mix of excitement for such a great live song - as well as a classic by Priest - but the added elements was brand new to the audience. '98 Live Meltdown had obviously not even been recorded yet and this gig was only the 4th concert of that tour. The band was fresh and that song was the highlight of the show, pretty remarkable considering how awesome they did everything else. Another special moment was Night Crawler. The way Tim sang that outro was unnerving and downright creepy, the way the song was intended. Thing is, I saw Priest twice on the tours for Painkiller and both times they did Night Crawler and both times Rob was kind of bad. The band did the song on both of the gigs I saw on that tour and both times they easily destroyed the '90 and '91 efforts with Rob.
I accept that I will always be in the minority here but the Tim Owens era is extremely underrated and unfairly criticized just because Halford was absent. Interesting how people could not accept Rob out of the band but can accept both K.K. and now Glenn out of the band when they were very much more vital to the identity of Priest than Rob was. The Owens era showed someone else could be Rob Halford but 2011-present era shows that no one else can be K.K. & Glenn and still be Judas Priest.