Register Forgot login?

© 2002-2014
Encyclopaedia Metallum

Best viewed
without Internet Explorer,
in 1280 x 960 resolution
or higher.

75% recorded in the studio, 25% live - 60%

Metal_Thrasher90, July 10th, 2013

Good times finally came for Thin Lizzy after the years of blood, sweat and tears. In the late 70’s they achieved their biggest success and recognition, musically the Irish guys were are their best so it was a good choice to think about a live album. It was time to discover if Thin Lizzy was a studio band or a live band, and see if their talent was real because the studio tactics and tricks can fool everybody. This double long-play is supposed to include performances from the Hammersmith Odeon, London the 14th November ’76 and the Seneca College Fieldhouse, Toronto the 28th November ’77 gigs.

However, as we all know, there’s been controversy about if this was a real live recording or a studio fake. Producer Tony Visconti made it clear: 75% recorded in the studio and 25% live. Their manager by that time says the opposite, but you know, if I had to believe somebody, I’d rely much more on the producer, who knows better about the original recording and mixing job.

So yes, this legendary live record has a lot of overdubs and studio tricks and traps, it is said that Lynott modified later some of his vocals as well. It wasn’t that hard to guess because the band sounds extremely perfect and competent on stage, with 0 mistakes, total perfection during the whole set so they must be inhuman gods if this wasn’t overdubbed. There’s no doubt about the talent of this group to make a great performance live, but this record doesn’t give you the chance to check it out by your own ears and get a real proof, because is not a true concert recording. There’s many other elements that make that clear: incredibly loud clapping and screaming from the crowd, which sound like if they were in Wembley or some other huge stadium when the truth is that they were playing in smaller places than that. The crowd also disappears and reappears all of a sudden during the long-play, something suspecting indeed because the noise from people is supposed to be constant, but in the moments when the band play low and quiet, there’s no sign of life out there. At times, guitars sound excessively brilliant for a concert performance, in particular some solos that are too polished, immaculate and elaborated, nothing to do with what we were used to hear from Robertson, like on “Still In Love With You” and “Don’t Believe A Word”. Whether this is live or studio stuff, one thing is clear: Lizzy is one of those bands that doesn’t offer anything unpredictable or modify the studio structures, even play note by note the riffs, harmonies, solos, licks, etc. Maybe the only variation from the original tunes of the previous records can be found on some pickin’ parts or alternative verses by Lynott, for example on the Bob Seger cover “Rosalie”, “Jailbreak” or “Suicide”. So if this is 75% from studio sessions, then it’s the best and most outrageous this band ever did, with a killer powerful production. Guitars in particular sound immense on “Emerald”, “Massacre” and “Warrior”, nothing to do with the 1st studio versions, these 2nd have more passion, energy and fury.

The recording captures a remarkable display of potential and abilities of the Irish rockers, who are brilliant on the instrumental exhibition of “Dancing In The Moonlight” which features the classy John Earl’s saxophone, or the unreleased new tracks “Are You Ready?” and “Baby Drive Me Crazy” with Huey Lewis on harmonica. Lynott introduces the gang and the fake audience sing along in these. The most intense moment comes with the 3 classics in a row: “The Boys Are Back In Town”, “Don’t Believe A Word” and “Cowboy Song”, which sound harder, faster and loose if you compare them with the cold first editions. Both Gorham and Robbo sound extraordinary, with screaming rough guitars taking complete control with virtuosism and strenght. Phil’s voice is pure delight, his greatest vocal work ever as you can hear in the frantic “The Rocker” and “Johnny The Fox Meets Jimmy The Weed”, demonstrating his great charisma and charming presence. Downey has his moment of glory in the “Sha La La” drum solo, that is not incredibly technical, creative or lenghty but enjoyable, in particular those distorted cymbals sound really impressing, reminded me of Cozy Powell’s from the Rainbow second album. The set-list is quite predictable, with the exception of that scandalous lack of numbers from the Bad Reputation long-play. The worthless Eric Bell years stuff is ignored and forgotten with the exception of the final tune, and we must be grateful for that. So the final result is solid for a studio record, I just wish they didn’t cheat and admited the undisputed truth and facts instead of fooling the fans. About the question if Lizzy are a live group or a studio group, well I guess fifty fifty, because they are not offering something impressive or different from what we heard on the studio work, apart from a much more powerful sound.

It is said that live albums, specially double ones, always mean the end of an era for a band, that’s exactly what happened in this case. Robertson was kicked out, Moore joined them once again and the sound changed slightly. This was the final release of the guitar combo Scott-Robbo line-up that gave us the finest music from this group and the most memorable. As a diehard Lizzy fan I am, I listened many many other live CDs from them, including those unnecessary post-Lynott 90’s and 21st century tribute era, and none of them satisfied me as much as this one, maybe because it’s fake and had been polished to the extreme in the Paris Studio Des Dames...or maybe because it has some really magic, unique and special moments.

Are You Out There? - 100%

Acrobat, September 4th, 2008

So yeah, my perfect album. This isn't something disposable to me... I didn't just pick this one up in Sainsburys and then progress to the fruit and veg aisle. Your mum may well be able to hum these tunes, but this is in no way housewife-friendly background music which they can take their medication and put babies in microwaves to. These are my anthems and it takes something of a very high quality and depth to achieve that status... well, I do hold myself in very high regard.

You can call me hackneyed and jaded in a sort of "standing on your mama's porch you said that it would last forever" way for having my own special songs. I can go for months without listening to this (not that I'd want to) and I'd still be able to recall every moment of this album. 'Live and Dangerous', to me, is perfect in every sense of the word; the timing of its release, the performance, the iconic cover art, the band's chemistry - a perfect combination of in-fighting and street gang bravado - and of course Mr Lynott's engrossing tales of vagabonds, rogues and cowboys.

To understand just why 'Live and Dangerous' is so good, one must be aware of what other live shows were like in the late 1970s. Zeppelin were the archetypal rock monoliths, but in the live arena they were too bloated, what with all the excessive drum solos and Robert Plant going "Ahhh Ahh Ahh" for five minutes on end. Sure, the folk segues were a nice little breather, but as Brian Adams once said - the kids wanna rock. At the other end of the spectrum you had the emerging punk scene and though I won't say they all sucked live (far from it, indeed, The Ramones' 'It's Alive' is one of few live records that can hold its own against 'Live and Dangerous'). But on the whole the punk bands were often more concerned with spitting and fighting against the establishment rather than becoming truly great live acts.

Make no mistake about it, 'Live and Dangerous' is an effortlessly commercial record; truly the work of a 'band of the people'. These songs can posthumously fill arenas and sell jeans, tampons, Swiss army knives... whatever, it doesn't matter. All commerce aside Lizzy are still my band. No amount of overplaying can kill them, they always will remain my band. Zeppelin, are one of my favourite hard rock bands who are now clearly in the public domain - the BBC and general public keep trying to ruin them for me. Zeppelin are subject to all sorts of horrors, be it kids referring to 'Mothership' as "Their new album" or Jimmy Page scraping away any rock credibility he has by playing at Olympic ceremonies. Lizzy, despite being an immensely well known and loved band in Britain are not subject to the same abhorrence. Johnny Dolequeue, your standard North Yorkshire no-hoper, may well be able to blurt out 'The Boys are Back in Town' after nine pints of Eurobeater, but I'll be damned if he can tell me just why Brian Robertson is so cool. Also the BBC tends to keep its greasy mits away from Lizzy, so all this and more means that this album is untouchable.

And for the music? Well, this is a collection taken from nearly all of Lizzy's classic albums... so this has a cat in hells chance of sucking. But not only do you have essentially the cream of the crop of Thin Lizzy, but you have an absolutely perfectly paced live performance. Lizzy are the masters of tension and excitement in the live environment. The opening salvo of 'Jailbreak' gets things off to the great start with its tight, muscular riffing. It rocks so hard you can overlook the silly lyric of 'tonight there's gonna be a jailbreak somewhere in the town'. Well, I'm no Cagney or Lacey... but I'd try the jail first. Never ones to keep an audience waiting next up is 'Emerald' which really acts as a bit of premature ejaculation for guitar fans. The song itself would be what you could label as a wholly sincere take on folk ideas from a hard rock band (I'll refrain from using the term folk metal). Brian Downey's drums take on a rolling almost Bodhrán-like feel and Phil tells a tale which conjures images of celtic battles (you know, Mel Gibson movie fare), again it's convincing and powerful rather than trite as it could of easily been. The guitar solos are simply otherworldly in their excellence, they should be framed in placed in galleries (preferably replacing whatever Tracy Emin has shat out this week). Robbo in particular steals the show, he crafts near celtic melodies in his playing which strengthens the epic feel of the song. This is what a guitar solo should be, you get your allocated space to work magic and the band works with you rather than simply playing a drab chord progression to give your wankery a backing (fuck you John Mayer!). It should be noted that during the solo section Phil's bass playing is a bit more busy and perfectly accents the solo. In short: this is guitar playing... get the fuck out of my house Joe Bonamassa.

It is quite a noteworthy achievement of this record that it maintains a streetwise everyman sense of story telling (much like Bruce Springsteen... but without the cheesy yankee fare) whilst still appealing to the musos out there. I suppose it comes with the combination of immensely tight song craft with perfectly honed performances. Brian Downey's performance is an example of this, he is without doubt a very fine drummer with a distinctively neat style and sound, but he never overplays... even his bloody drum solo is the right length! But everything about this performance is ruthlessly efficient yet not lacking in warm or soul, much like a strategic grope on a girl you've liked for a long time or crushing a kitten's skull with a breeze block because it would grow up to be the next Hitler.

Not all of the songs here actually made it onto the live set. 'Southbound' for instance is taken from an inspired sound check performance. It acts as a beautiful, gentle comedown after the celtic battle hymn 'Emerald'. Whereas, the 'Bad Reputation' version came across as a little dulcet, especially in the guitar harmony, this performance is far more ernest, heartfelt and even with a lot more balls than the studio version. Never once were Lizzy caught sans testicles in a live environment. Picking up the pace once again is another song which really outshines its studio counterpart, 'Rosalie'. A crowd favourite (which Motörhead have actually been playing of late) and strikingly simple in its execution but with an astounding energy. 'Dancing in the Moonlight' once again shows the great use of tension and mood changes that Lizzy had in their live show. This version is a little less funky and more guitar driven (with the notable addition of some harmonies under the saxophone solo) than the 'Bad Reputation' version and that's fine by me, what's the point of having two identikit versions? Scott thankfully plays the solo faithfully to the original and it's crisp and lighter than most of the solos here, especially with that descending octave lick. Also worthy of note is that this version is a little darker than the original single, what with less studio polish which came in the form of hand claps and finger clicks, and more of a beautiful pathos in Lynott's vocals.

For some reason, hard rock giants in the 1970s always had the knack of delivering absolutely killer slow blues songs, Purple's 'Mistreated', Zeppelin's 'Since I've Been Loving You' and The Osmonds had 'Crazy Horses'. Here we have Lizzy's 'Still in Love With You' and perhaps the best of the lot. A slow blues is very easy to make a arse-over-tits job of, if you give the wrong guitarist - a minor key, sparse chord progression they may well just go ballistic and disappear up their own arse. Thankfully, no one ego completely overrules Lizzy (though at times it certainly was Phil's) and the vocals and both guitarists get sufficient time to shine and never at the expense at the expense of the song. The verses give Phil a chance to deliver quite possibly his most passionate vocal performance ever and the lyrical simplicity of the song really allows his emotions to come through. Robbo's solo (yes I am aware of the level of analysis I'm placing on individual solos, but they're that good) is a long one for this album but it's perfectly crafted and well accented by the drums. The subtle use of tremolo picking is almost ethereal in the emotions it conveys, which isn't normally a feeling I would associate with the technique. But most guitarists wouldn't really have you associating techniques with emotion, unless it is Steve Vai and the emotion is nausea. 'Still in Love With You' really is a triumph and contributes to the album's perfect sense of light and shade.

After this and 'Johnny the Fox' (perhaps the albums weaknest number, but still far preferable to any other rock band's foray into funkier territory) we are bombarded with rockers. After all the teasing of the first half of the album finally it's time for some balls-to-the-wall rock. 'The Cowboy Song' goes from melancholic ballad to shuffling rocker. The song has a fantastic sense of movement to it, I don't think any idea is repeated more than twelve times in succession, meaning nothing has time to stagnate and the song seems to be finished all too soon... not that it feels incomplete. 'The Boys Are Back in Town' arrives mid-set, which is unusual for the band's best known song, still it works amazingly well. It's got that butterflies-in-your-stomach excitement to it and sums up the band's gang-like attitude perfectly. It may be overplayed, but with good reason. You can just picture Scott and Robbo running up to the microphones and blurting out the backing vocals then running off again like school boys after too much lemonade and sherbet to play that world-beating guitar harmony. A feminist would perhaps single some of the lyrics out as sexist, but this raises the question - why is she listening to music when she should be preparing her spouse/father/abuser's next meal? The album continues with this fine rocking and big tunes till its finale after the greatly reinvigorated 'Rocker'. This song acts as one final solid ball of rock, anymore would have been unnecessary... always leave 'em wanting more, right?

Come to thing of it, that's exactly Lizzy did... or at least this line-up, the Fab Four would never record an album again. 'Live and Dangerous' acts as one final hurrah from Lizzy's classic era. After this album Robbo's ego got in the way one too many times and he was out, Scott and Phil got involved in harder drugs and Brian Downey spent his fortune on dog eggs. RIP Phil Lynott... Heaven has more leather trews and Irish half-castes with you there.