Register Forgot login?

© 2002-2015
Encyclopaedia Metallum

Best viewed
without Internet Explorer,
in 1280 x 960 resolution
or higher.

Senmuth - Madinat al-Mayyit - 60%

ConorFynes, January 9th, 2011

As a composer who finds the time to write at least ten albums a year on average, it's understandable that many of Valery Av's creations cannot necessarily be considered revolutions in his sound. Although there has been a gradual change (and some might say 'improvement') from heavy upbeat metal to more ambient and experimental sounds, developments from album to album are generally minuscule, at times even regressing back to older styles. 'Madinat al-Mayyit' was the album that closed out 2009 for Senmuth, and while certainly an able ethnic album on it's own, it is still only retracing ground covered years ago, and now time and time again.

Upon first listen, I instantly recognized this as having alot in common with sound with an earlier album 'Path Of Satiam.' Being one of my most enjoyed releases from Senmuth thus far, 'Path Of Satiam' had many of the things that makes Senmuth an interesting musical project. What 'Madinat al-Mayyit' seems to do is take the same style, but add a dimension of doom metal into it. While this does work to varying effects on the music here, the songwriting here isn't nearly as good as 'Satiam' and in parts, even feels completely ripped off the parent album... Hell, 'Baalbek' feels like a note for note rendition of a 'Satiam' song! The totally derivative nature of this album aside, it is a welcome addition to Senmuth, and while the musical ideas here aren't catchy by any standard, there are some very interesting moments scattered about.

The execution and production here is nothing special, but functional and pushes the composition forward quite well. The instruments here sound more authentic than they usually do on a Senmuth record, and the music is generally driven by Senmuth's palette of Middle- Eastern instrument sounds.

Arabic for 'dead city,' Senmuth's 'Madinat al-Mayyit' does stand out musically from many of the other pieces Senmuth has to offer, but it fails to crawl out of the shadow of it's predecessor 'Path Of Satiam.'

Middle-eastern uprising - 86%

Crick, May 23rd, 2009

Arguably, one of the most thrown around terms in music could be considered "soul". When describing a particular instrument or song, I've often heard many a music fan claim an instrument has a very "soulful" sound, which more or less didn't help in their description of the music at all. I think at the time I was just ignorant to the ability of a musical instrument to have "soul". Now, don't get me wrong, prior to hearing this album I'd heard plenty of songs with such a description and recognized playing of the soulful sort. But this album really is an exercise in making music with that kind of force, that kind of personality.

Essentially, this album is not overtly complex in a technical sense. Rhythmically and layerwise, there are indeed many different melodies melding and mixing at once, but they stay within the realm of straightforward yet winding composition. Where one melody ends, another begins with seamless transition that would appear to carry forward the previous one. Continuity is huge here, and it's without a doubt a strong point of the work. However, even the most solidly played music still has to have some kind of charm to it's production value or it becomes an empty, hollowed out shell of media garbage.

This album does not suffer from such a problem. As always, Senmuth's production job is top-notch - however, here is where his tinkerings with tonality shine through more noticeably than on other works. Primarily the main instruments are a sitar, a violin and ethnic percussion - each produce a very wide variety of tones and sounds. I particularly like the violin's, as it's not the soft and rounded kind that violin enthusiasts are more accustomed to. It feels crisp, more cutting than usual. It lends itself well to the very middle-eastern atmosphere here and really pulls at your heartstrings on songs like "Levant" - again, it demonstrates the quality of "soul" very well.

The sitar could arguably considered the most complex of all instruments on "Madinat al-Mayitt". Senmuth's emphasis on sitar melodies is very much so at the forefront of many of the compositions here. "Ain Dara" and "Serjillah", for example, are almost carried forward by the transitions in sitar melodies. Many of the sitar tunes are also very catchy -- a definite plus for those looking for memorable tunes. However, staying true to Senmuth's industrial metal roots, the sitar also often melds with electric guitar. "Qatoure" showcases a very odd feel of very heavy guitar that manages to plow forward yet not really "chug" in that annoying fashion critics of modern industrial metal so often bring up.

The marrying of electronic, industrial and metal music is another facet of modern industrial metal that happens rather often here. Electronic melodies are more sparse than other Senmuth works, but have an important role in backing the other instruments and ocassionally coming to the front to add to a particularly "modern" atmosphere - almost as if our technological world has assimilated the old ways of the middle east and created a new world where they "fit in". Such artsy claims may seem contrived, but this album does indeed often sound very sad and mournful for a culture that's long since been perverted by the world's ever changing society.

Finally, I'd like to note "Ishtar". This may be the most straightforward metal song present on "Madinat al-Mayitt", though it still takes a few minutes to get there due to Senmuth's experimental nature. Once it does get going though, you're treated to rapid industrial riffs with a thick yet razor-like tone (again emphasizing tonality) that builds up to one of Senmuth's most powerful solos yet. Definitely a highlight of an already very powerful album (though it has some hindrances, such as "Ziqqurat"s somewhat overly synthetic production issues or an odd track transition). I recommend this to those who want a real taste of middle-eastern music, rather than whatever progressive radio-friendly spew Orphaned Land have been making.

Highlights: Ain Dara, Ishtar, Qatoure, Ebla, Qalb Lozeh, Levant