Register Forgot login?

© 2002-2017
Encyclopaedia Metallum

Best viewed
without Internet Explorer,
in 1280 x 960 resolution
or higher.

Did I get the Sonny & Cher version of this album? - 61%

TrooperEd, April 13th, 2017
Written based on this version: 2001, CD, EMI (Remastered)

I'm beginning to think Sin After Sin, Stained Class and Killing Machine should start losing points for giving birth to a stereotype that if a metal band which accomplished commercial success in the 80s put out albums in the 70s, those albums are infinitely heavier then their 80s counterparts. I've spent about a good decade and a half peeking over the fence at Scorpions, but if only a record company could put out a greatest hits collection that had both eras of the band that wasn't double disc or so miserably expensive. Hearing this in full, I was right to be cautions.

I will gladly admit that Sails of Charon is everything it's hyped up to be and more. Writing credit faux-pas be damned, it's a crying shame the band never played this live at all. This is power metal majesty at it's finest, easily the Scorps masterpiece. He's A Woman, She's A Man ain't too shabby either, though I think calling it proto-thrash might be a bit too generous. With that being said, if you have those two songs on mp3, you've heard everything you have to hear from this album. We'll Burn the Sky has a decent riff, but some days of the week it just gets run into the ground. When I find myself asking when the damn guitar solo is gonna start already, I seem to snap out of a trance and unfortunately realize I was already about halfway through it. Then I have to rewind. I hate rewinding. Guys, placing a generic riff or chord strum under your guitar solo section in order to accentuate it is not the horrid crime you think it is. Hell Iron Maiden were masters at it.

The rest of the album isn't trash, but it's rigged with problems that an album with this kind of reputation should not have. Those problems include laughably stupid lyrics (Steamrock Fever), too much 70s rock and not enough metal (I've Got To Be Free, Your Light), and the vocals being way too poppy-bouncy (The Riot of Your Time). There's catchy, and then there's distracting. And yes, some of these problems are indeed the trappings of one Ulrich Roth. Roth is unquestionably one hell of a guitar player, proudly carrying on a tonal legacy of Jimi Hendrix. Your Light would have made one hell of a Band of Gypsys track. But people laud him like he was Randy Rhoads before Randy Rhoads; as though he was THE metal component of the band. He did write the aforementioned Sails of Charon after all. But you know what he didn't write? Dynamite; Can't Get Enough; Don't Make No Promises (Your Body Can't Keep). Not to demonize the man but if he was just so metal, he should have gone on to have a career similar to Yngwie Malmsteen, Steve Vai or at least Stevie Ray Vaughn, but he didn't. The Scorpions seemed to do OK without him.

My dear reader, definitely make sure you have a copy of Sails of Charon on your iPod shuffle. But if you're looking for a rock band from the 70s with strong metal overtones and/or credentials, go pick yourself up some Thin Lizzy. Or Blackout.

P.S. Am I the only one who thinks the second half of Born To Touch Your Feelings should have been the credits music to the obesely morbid anime Grave Of The Fireflies?

Unstoppable Force - 98%

SweetLeaf95, October 20th, 2015

Nearing the end of the decade, Scorpions put out one of their last records of the '70s, in which I call their climax for this time period, mixing their original styles with styles yet to prevail. In 1977, Taken By Force was dropped, and is without a doubt my favorite record of theirs from the 1970's. There's only so much you can package into one magnificent release, and they touch just about all of it here.

In this record, you will hear some of the greatest guitar work ever displayed in the early heavy metal years. Imagine taking the beautiful compositions displayed on their debut album Lonesome Crow, and mixing it with a harder, yet more refined sound, as well as played by a different guitarist, Ulrich Roth. All of them are played with such melodic complexion, yet a harder edge at the same time. "We'll Burn The Sky" is probably the greatest example of this, mostly because of the solo in the outro, but it's pretty solid the whole way through as well. This song also contains some of the softer guitar parts which makes for a stellar mix of guitar tracks. The same can be said about the bass on here, as it's very audible and plays such a large role in the musical make-up. As it makes for a great layout for the faster guitar parts, it's also perfect for the slower parts. Take "Your Light" for example, as it acts as a bridge between vocals parts along with the guitar. Overall, the musical composition on this record is nearly perfect, and would make it a tough one to top.

As well as the music itself, Klaus's vocals are at some of their finest as well. Most people could recognize it by hearing it, as it has a distinct sound. Here, we see a lot of signs of a more powerful approach, and what one would expect in the '80s records, such as on Animal Magnetism. At the same time, we can see influences from the earlier work, most evident on my favorite track, "I've Got To Be Free". While melody is vastly important, the enthusiasm and lack of holding back any air is what makes it so great. This kind of vocal output on top of the guitar work makes for the perfect track, and if you're not that familiar with Scorpions, I would highly recommend this one as a starter. With a variety of guitar sounds and vocal work, this album sure packs in a lot of beautiful tunes all across the spectrum.

Of course, there's one thing I missed. You can't talk about this album without mentioning "He's A Woman, She's A Man". The last thing that tops this album off is the earliest sign of speed metal riffing, and is often credited as one of the first. Arguably, it's between this, Black Sabbath's "Symptom Of The Universe", and Judas Priest's "Exciter". But this track was the perfect way to tie everything together, by adding some harsher sounds to the classic metal sounds, softer calm parts, and signs of what would come in the future with a lot of melody mixed in. The only thing stopping this record from getting 100% is that the second half of the last track "Born To Touch Your Feelings" is really annoying, as it's just a bunch of whispering voices overlaying a guitar part. It gets old really fast. Other than that, this record is borderline perfect and could catch the attention of anyone who digs traditional metal, classic guitar composition, early rock sounds, and speed/thrash.

Taken by Force by the Best Metal Album of the 70’ - 95%

bayern, March 21st, 2012

Scorpions’ “Taken by Force” is the best metal album of the 70’s (with Black Sabbath’s ‘Master of Reality” a close second, of course); period. Throwing the safest bridge between the heavy, brooding riffage of early Sabbath and the more aggressive trends of the 80’s (speed and thrash, that is), which at this stage had only been slightly hinted at, if at all, this pivotal album is anything an early metal fan would look for. And this is the album on which the Scorps finally found themselves: the road more or less travelled had already started with “In Trance”, but the metallic numbers were dissipated by too many ballads, a tendency which was closely followed on “Virgin Killer” as well. So the band needed something as compulsively aggressive as this in order to take off... by force. And here it was:

The brutal shred of the opening “Steamrock Fever” was one of the first signs at the time that something more ominous and intense was going to come in a few years; a thrash/speed metal precursor second to none, this track also saw Meine acquiring a more sinister tone to fit the aggressive guitar approach. Frowns would inevitably appear on the listener’s face, after hearing the opening cords of the next “We’ll Burn the Sky”, but later on this song contains some of the most compulsive headbanging riffs of the decade, the guys shredding like demented turning this song into one of the mandatory tracks in the band’s catalogue.

So far, so great… The band’s past shows up briefly on the next two cuts, both mild heavy rockers with a big hit potential, far from a disappointment, but totally overshadowed by “The Sails of Charon”: a superb power/doomster with some of the darkest, most brooding riffs around at the time, and some of the greatest lead guitar work to ever grace a metal album: yes, the Scorps suffered a great loss when Uli Roth left after this album’s release. Time for rest (you’ll need it, trust me!) with the more radio-friendly “Your Light”, before the explosion which “He’s a Woman, She’s a Man” is: thrash metal was literally born with this piece making the Motorhead speedy rock’n roll boogies at the time sound like an infant lullaby. No wonder quite a few speed/thrash metal acts (Evildead, Helstar, Helloween) have picked this song to pay tribute to its pioneering, groundbreaking, significance.

Even the kindergarden children know that Scorpions used to end their albums with a ballad so “Born to Touch Your Feelings” should come as no surprise to both the more and less initiated, one of the most romantic songs the band have ever come up with, but its impact would be minimal after the preceding “carnage”, and may remain hardly noticed at first listen. And here we are, at the end of this roller-coaster of a metal album.

Logically the band followed it with their first recorded live performance (“Tokyo Tapes”) right after, having finally accumulated enough hard-hitting numbers to rock the heads of the fans worldwide. With the future course well outlined now, the guys’ way to the top was fairly clear, not without the guitar wizard Roth’s leaving after a clash with the rest as to what direction the band’s style should take from then on. Without him the band’s approach became colder and less melodic, and arguably less striking, but this proved no obstacle for the making of other great efforts, like “Animal Magnetism, “Blackout”, etc.

Gracefully topping the “holy three” of 70’s metal (the other two: the aforementioned Black Sabbath’s “Master of Reality”, and Judas Priest’s ‘Stained Class”), this great album may not sound as impressive nowadays, if taken (by force) as a whole, but the superior side largely compensates for the several pitfalls which were a pretty common occurrence for the metal albums at the time when older and younger practitioners were still looking for their most-fitting face, experimenting with all kinds of influences and nuances, more or less metal-related. Did the Scorps ever manage to top it up? Well, this is a polemical question, but it’s undeniable that with it in sight the way to “Blackout” and “Love at First Sting” seemed way clearer. And the journey on Charon’s boat by all means safer…

One of the Best 70's Metal Albums - 96%

DawnoftheShred, August 9th, 2007

Germany’s Scorpions were a force to be reckoned with…. in the 70’s. This early period is often unheralded in light of the commercial success they’d achieve in the following decade, but it is undoubtedly the era in which they were the most powerful, musically speaking. They were once a band that weren’t so concerned with writing hits and selling records that they forgot to put their hearts and souls into their songwriting. This is the band they still were for 1977’s Taken by Force: a band of integrity and musicianship forging a new sound that combined their psychedelic rock roots with the soaring harmony leads and intense riffage of proto-power metal. I haven’t heard their entire back catalogue at this point, but I feel it’s safe to say that this is their finest recording.

Taken by Force was the last album to feature one Ulrich Roth, the most talented guitar player they’d ever have in their lineup. Sure, Mathias Jabs is good, as are the brothers Schenker, but Uli was the best. Roth and Rudolph Schenker deliver the performance of a lifetime on here, trading solos and crunchy riffs that would shame the band’s later work. Klaus Meine is also in rare form; his voice still resounding with energy and conviction. This energy is noticeable immediately in opener “Steamrock Fever,” a surprisingly heavy rocker with a delightfully catchy chorus. This treatment is repeated throughout the album, but this time around, Meine’s catchy chorus melodies aren’t the sole departure in an otherwise uninteresting song (as would be the case in their post-Blackout material). Quality instrumentation exudes from every pore of this album, from Roth’s undeniably Hendrix-inspired “I’ve Got to be Free” and “Your Light,” to cult classic “He’s a Woman, She’s a Man,” which has one riff that can’t really be misconstrued as anything but a thrash riff. There’s a notably darker tone on this album than on later ones, apparent not only in the phrasing, but in some of the subject matter. “The Riot of Your Time” is not the upbeat rocker that would have garnered mainstream attention in ’84 like one chart-topping song about rocking like hurricanes, while power ballads “We’ll Burn the Sky” and “Born to Touch Your Feelings” are infinitely more haunting than “Still Loving You” would be.

But the absolute highlight of this album is side two’s opener, “The Sails of Charon.” A Roth masterpiece, it’s the best Scorpions song ever composed. Carried by Roth’s exotic opening rhythms, an unstoppable groove, Meine’s inimitable vocal melody, a plethora of ear-pleasing harmonies, and one of the most brilliant intro solos ever conceived, it’s one of the best metal songs of the 1970’s, even in light of Black Sabbath’s early discography. Plus there are those lyrics; darker and more ominous than anything else they’ve ever done. “Dark night! There is no light in the realm of the black magic man!” This could be the only song on the album and it’d still be the best thing they’ve ever released.

This is a mandatory purchase for any Scorpions fans, especially fans of their later material who don’t know what they’re missing.

Highlights: “The Sails of Charon,” “We’ll Burn the Sky,” “He’s a Woman, She’s a Man”

A Masterpiece from the 70’s - 90%

Hammertime, March 24th, 2005

Taken By Force is one of the finest releases from The Scorpions. I like the darker sound that Scorpions had in their early days. Former Scorpions guitarist Uli Roth did some great heavy lyrics also on Taken By Force album. Your Light and The Sails Of Charon contains very dark lyrics and both are very good songs also. The album starts with fast and catchy track Steamrock Fever. Klaus Meine’s vocals sound different than usual on this song and I do like the rough singing in this one. The greatest song of this album is definitely We’ll Burn The Sky. It is a perfect half-ballad and I think it’s much better than the more popular slower Scorpions classics. Meine’s singing is awesome again. The song starts slow but the chorus part is heavy and catchy. In my opinion We’ll Burn The Sky is one of the greatest songs on the long career of Scorpions. It it sad, melancholic and beautiful. I’ve Got To Be Free is a simple rocker, but a good one. The Riot Of Your Time contains dark atmosphere which was quite typical element in the 70’s Scorpions. Next comes the two Uli Roth songs The Sails Of Charon and Your Light that contain even satanic feeling on their lyrics. When I listen to those songs they remind me of old Black Sabbath which is a cool thing. He’s A Woman, She’s A Man is a funny song but a kind of a legend. After this fast rocker comes the last song of the album Born To Touch Your Feelings. It is a very typical thing that Scorpions close their album with a ballad. In fact the song is good but too long for my taste. There are some women from different countries to spell some words in the end of the song. They speak different languages so it’s hard to find out what they’re saying. In my opinion that outro part is too long and boring.

Overall Taken By Force is a very good album and I’ll recommend it to everyone who likes solid 70’s heavy rock (bands like Black Sabbath, Led Zeppelin, Deep Purple, Uriah Heep etc.). For Scorpions fans this is the “must have” record. The original version of the album had brilliant cover art and it’s a pity that the remaster cover isn’t the same. But that’s not a big deal. The remaster contains two bonus tracks: Suspender Love and Polar Nights (live). Suspender Love is a cool rock song with a fine chorus. Polar Nights is an Uli Roth song full of guitar jamming. It is taken from Tokyo Tapes live album. The remaster version of Tokyo Tapes doesn’t have this track on it, because the length of the album.

If you have heard only newer Scorpions stuff and a few radio ballads then you should listen to this album and change your view of this band. Although you don’t like the 80’s, the 90’s or even newer Scorpions stuff you still might enjoy this album.