Register Forgot login?

© 2002-2017
Encyclopaedia Metallum

Best viewed
without Internet Explorer,
in 1280 x 960 resolution
or higher.

Primitive Man - Scorn (2013) - 90%

Anti_Christ666, December 22nd, 2013

Originally written for Music Talk
Primitive Man is a three-piece sludge/doom trio based out in the open spaces of Colorado, United States. The band tore the scene wide open with their first release, Scorn, and after circulating rapidly throughout the metal community, the band has quickly earned a reputation for their punishing sound that combines sludge and doom metal with elements of noise. Ethan McCarthy, of Clinging to the Trees of a Forest Fire, takes on vocals and guitar, Isidro Soto on drums, and Jonathan Campos completes the lineup on bass. Scorn created numerous waves within the scene within a short amount of time, and I believe it to be one of the best releases from the sludge genre this year. Without further ado, let the dissection begin!

Scorn opens with the title track, an 11 minute ripper that assaults the listeners ears with the unrelenting attack of heavily distorted guitars, powerful drums, and a screeching noise that is always present in the background. The band pummels away, with a fury, during the entire duration of the song, never letting up once to allow the listener some breathing space. The following track, Rags, continues the assault in a similar vein of Scorn, finally allowing the listener to recoup with the track I Can't Forget, a 3 minute song utilizing mostly ambience noise and effects. The break is short lived, however, as the next track, Antietam, once again tears away at the listener in a maniacal fashion. The track begins with a slow, trance-like riff that eventually builds to a speed assault with equally an equally powerful groove. The atmosphere from track to track is one of hatred and destruction, and the songs are very well composed, featuring numerous sections of fast and slow, blast beats and simple grooves, etc. Primitive Man successfully utilize all the tools at their disposal to craft a record of ultimate hatred and misanthropy, a must-have for those individuals with similar world views and ideas. Not a fan of the human hatred topic? Not to fear, Primitive Man still provides the listener with much to pay attention to and enjoy musically.

The album is very well produced, but not overproduced. Everything is clearly audible and everything has it's own space within the final mix. I particularly like the drum sound on this record because it's not overbearingly huge, but it sounds large enough to contribute to the overall heaviness that is Primitive Man. The noise elements within this album are also well mixed. They are not overbearing, irritating, or degrading to the ear, yet they still convey the atmosphere of hatred and misanthropy that laces each song. Well done on the production!

Isidro Soto does a great job with the drum work on this record. His drum kit sounds awesome, he has an excellent handle on rhythm, time, what to play, and how to play it. Everything is well executed and everything packs a punch, from the simple rock beats to the blast beat madness. Keep up the great work, Isidro!

Scorn is a record truly deserving of its' title. The songs are well composed, the atmosphere is memorable, and the lyrics tie it all together. Not only that, but the album cover and the elements of noise help further cement a feeling of discontent and distaste for the very beings that we are. Primitive Man is definitely a band I will continue to watch in the future. They have great command of their instruments and they have a clear direction to pursue. If you are a fan of sludge, you need to pick up this record. In a small amount of time, Scorn has become a staple in my listening rotation, and I hope this record finds a good home in your library as well.

Only dissonance is real. - 90%

Inspector_Satan, February 20th, 2013

Having been a fan of frontman Ethan McCarthy's project Clinging to the Trees of a Forest Fire for a while now, my anticipation for this release was sky high especially after the release of "Visceral" in 2011, which saw them incorporating elements of funeral doom into their usual brand of frenzied "funeral grind." Over the 16 and some odd minutes of it's runtime the band seamlessly jumps from a crawl to a full on assault, tied together by their unique riffs and note choices. Scorn is a natural continuation of that sound, yet retaining the same unyielding commitment to anti-consonance.

The first thing that caught my attention about this release is just how massive everything sounds. Bass and guitars are downtuned and loud, and both possess a rich fuzzy distortion that really serves to emphasize the low end and really rounds out their sound. Drums are punchy and full bodied and sit perfectly in the mix. Ethan's vocals have always been one of the major standout factors to his work for me and he's honestly never sounded more at home here, his caustic shrieks cutting fiercely through the dense atonal sludge of the riffs driving home the intensity of the work.

As mentioned before, Scorn is heavy. REALLY FUCKING HEAVY. Much of the album is spent somewhere between a drunken stagger and a punishing crawl which works quite well for them. Tracks begin and end with noise as would befit any grind act. The dissonance of their riffing when given some proper breathing room tends to yield an unsettling effect, which is often bolstered by the inclusion of feedback or fret noise in the more sparse passages. That's not to say the album is all set at that pace, in songs like the title track and Antietam will explode out of nowhere into a brief but furious crusty charge, adding to the urgency of it the music settling back down. The most impressive part of it all and the thing that will likely add to its staying power are the way they can carve impossibly catchy riffs with a clever ear for unconventional melody. The song Rags fades out with a haunting arpeggiated chord progression laid down over a bed of feedback. The 9 minute epic Antietam's middle section's got a nasty grooving hook that gradually reduces in tempo as if it's falling apart before breaking completely down into noise. The sum of all it's parts work well together and keep the album interesting throughout.

This is an excellent first effort for the band and I look forward to whatever the future holds for them.

Scorn - 90%

todesengel89, February 14th, 2013

Essentially boasting the exact same lineup as the rather unique Clinging to the Trees of a Forest Fire, which completely got me hooked with their last EP Visceral, Primitive Man seems to be the band’s effort to push things to a further extreme, this time with the band adopting a more sludge/doom sound with their debut full length release Scorn.

The disturbing noise of feedback, and that dark, ominous atmosphere that hits the listener right from the start of the album pretty much gives a good introduction to the journey that Primitive Man has put in place for the listener. The music here is crushing as hell, and if one were not crushed by the heavy riffs, downtuned guitars and the rumbling bass itself, the suffocating atmosphere is sure to get one down, making it almost hard to breathe, and the somewhat psychedelic feel that the band engages in right from the start brings to mind bands such as Drug Honkey and their experimental form of doom metal.

The vocal styling of Ethan easily brings in the CTTTOAFF influences in Primitive Man‘s music, and this is most evident in the intensity that is present, though the tortured quality certainly shines through the music of Primitive Man even more with the abundance of slow sections on the album. Yet Primitive Man is more than just that (in fact, vastly different from the style of CTTTOAFF), as the band seems to pull in influences from quite a wide spectrum of genres. Despite being mainly a sludge/doom band, there are many moments where the band easily sounds like one of those oppressive death metal bands such as Impetuous Ritual and Portal, what with the coalescing of heavy riffs and the generous usage of feedback and various effects on the guitar to ensure that the listener is put under as much pressure as possible, especially on moments such as the middle of title track, Scorn.

The progression of Scorn can get extremely slow at times as well, and moments such as these help to build up the tension in the air. This also ensures that the experience of listening to the album is as excruciatingly painful as possible, allowing Primitive Man to slowly hammer and drill their messages of hopelessness and desolation into the listener. The band’s emphasis on the atmospheric aspect is also evident, with tracks like I Cant’t Forget and the disturbing sound samples on the track and throughout the album easily leaving one gasping desperately for air by the time the album ends.

With Scorn as the band’s debut release, Primitive Man has certainly set an extremely high benchmark for itself. It certainly leaves one to wonder how they will top this, and makes any fan of the band and their related projects eagerly anticipating for more from this trio.