Register Forgot login?

© 2002-2014
Encyclopaedia Metallum

Best viewed
without Internet Explorer,
in 1280 x 960 resolution
or higher.

Ode To Bates - 89%

Metal_Thrasher90, December 9th, 2014

Coroner had already achieved their status of cult underground thrash band by the early-90’s with 3 fantastic albums of seemingly never ending ideas and technical excellence, becoming the originators of the progressive thrash subgenre. They were one of those very few groups that presented a totally unique sound, eluding the stereotypes and clichés of a movement that was soon getting ordinary and generic as so many new bands were repeating the same formulas. By the late-80’s, a new trend began: power thrash, which gave melody, harmonies and complexity greater control, occasionally denying the roots of the subgenre and getting excessively cheesy and mellow – fortunately, Royce & co. were capable of making difficult music without necessarily getting too tender and polite, maintaining roughness still present in their songs. However, the new decade arrived with severe changes in the metal scene and these guys were forced to modify their schemes, inevitably.

Mental Vortex seems to be a transitory work, on which Coroner start pushing away thrash elements to concentrate substantially on progression and cadence of their music. Actually, tracks like “Semtex Revolution” and “Divine Step (Conspectu Mortis)” offer a weightier sound, essentially determined by heavier riffs and traditional tempos that deliberately avoid significant speed and dynamism. Those cuts are generally quieter and let’s say less-energetic in contrast with previous attempts. There are some lengthy slow-paced overlong breaks that reveal a distinct atmosphere and climax, not particularly violent, showing greater meticulousness from the Swiss thrashers. Velocity is decreased but not their innate fascination for complication - more predominantly casual tunes of ordinary tempos as “Sirens” and “Son Of Lilith” offer a large variety of riff variations of total innovation and creativity, which introduce some advanced instrumental sections of alternative nature and feel, providing admirable versatility to the music. Of course, there are rhythm changes you don’t expect and certain sequences of high speed and raging riffs, on which their thrash spirit reappears occasionally, however. “Metamorphosis” alternates more thrashy parameters with an even bigger dose of complexity - Coroner hardly repeat the same instrumental basis without adding extra modifications and arrangements constantly, structures evolve continuously, very heterogeneous as the title suggests. Number after number, these guys increase the level of technique and difficulty with dexterous rhythms of extreme detail and precision, vivid riffs in constant alteration and immaculately elaborated and designed instrumental passages on which they really display their superior talent with no place for improvisation or chaos. “About Life” and “Pale Sister” also incorporate melody and sophistication in bigger percentage, conceived by Baron’s lyrical lines, which experiment with assorted tones and textures.

We were already familiar with the instrumental supremacy of Coroner, so what’s new on Mental Vortex? They intended to refuse the trademark classic thrash characteristics, the vital speed and aggression to give their music bigger presence and power, including heavier tempos and riffs, focusing on its hugeness and cadence – yet not eluding completely vigor and energy, as I mentioned this is a transitory phase between their progressive thrash ways and the simply progressive ways they’d soon present on Grin. So there are still some frantic sequences and loose rhythms, along with amazingly abrasive riffs, which serve different purposes, higher ambition in contrast with some of their peers by that time. For thrash bands the concept of technical seemed to be an unavoidably synonym of cheesy in most cases, It couldn’t be intricate without getting also sweet, adding annoying high-range pitch vocals and an enormous bunch of harmonies and overtones. Royce & co.’s patterns were peculiar in that aspect as well, of course they made melody, technique and refinement part of their philosophy, at times really crucial to determine the basis and essence of some song-sequences – though always combined with roughness and sonic violence. Ron’s voice is considerably raspy, low-tuned and kinda harsh compared with a majority of power thrash singers. Some riffs are very crude too and never uniform in their configuration, Tommy T. will always impress us with variations nobody else would come up with, exploring different textures to make his parts richer and unpredictable, so this is a band clearly determined to break the limitations and topics of the subgenre, an attitude that made albums like Mental Vortex absolutely special. Their creativity and fresh ideas are memorable, their superb technical level had no equal either in a period when heavy metal was becoming minimalist, basic and conceived to satisfy wider audiences that just wouldn’t tolerate so much difficulty – this ain’t the kind of easy listening radio stuff that could accompany Metallica, Guns N’ Roses and Nirvana’s new singles.

Maybe it’s less thrashy and destructive but this album is still plenty of their unique virtuosism, progression and talent, different perspective doesn’t mean worst cheesier music this time. Coroner didn’t forget about their original concept, their methodology actually shows no particularly drastic changes because they still display as much complexity and technique as usual, it’s only that their music ain’t that fast and loose, raw and aggressive as it used to be – their sound has adapted distinct forms of ferocity heavier riffs and rhythms can also provide. Soon thrash would decay absolutely and only a few underground chosen ones would survive and get a decent record deal by inevitably denying their past and embracing alternative sounds…Grin is another part of the story, yet Mental Vortex is where Coroner achieved their own sound definitely without selling out, neither getting uninteresting nor groovy, undoubtedly an essential album – “Dead And Getting Deader”!

Longer - 84%

StainedClass95, July 25th, 2014

This is Coroner's fourth album, Mental Vortex This is not as great as No More Color, but the quality isn't drastically lower. This album reminds me of Into the Pandemonium. It's not as good as the previous few, it's very much weirder, but the quality of the stronger songs is definitely there.

The song structure on this album is more drawn out than before. These songs are a couple of minutes longer overall than they had been on the earlier albums. Part of this is that they are slower. I suspect that there was an interest in making this album heavier, as there is a bit more of an early groove vibe from this than from any of their early albums. I imagine that this is an influence from Metallica more than anything. Many bands were influenced by Master and Justice to slow down some of their songs. This strikes me as more of the latter, with the stretched out songs and colder vibe.

The vocals on this album are as normal. They have a distinct Warrior-flavoring, which works for him. His lyrics also have that flavor to them. They're very esoteric and even disconcerting at times. On Metamorphosis, there are some weird whale sounds in the intro that are legitimately creepy, and then it follows into some freaky Mr. Limpet lyrics. His bass-playing is by far the superior aspect of his contribution. He does have some good bass lines on this album, and apparently he does it all with his fingers. For some, this is more difficult, but for others, this can be easier. I do know it usually takes a little more concentration than playing with a pick.

The guitar playing isn't as enjoyable as usual. He doesn't shred as often, and he also isn't shining more than usual in any other areas. The longer composition approach works for many guitarists, but I think Tommy definitely worked better with shorter numbers with shred solos. The riffs here are a little odd for him. I would actually liken much of the playing here to Killing Technology. The difference here is that where Piggy used his energetic weirdness to his advantage, Tommy is more cutting himself off at the knees by not bringing his technique to bear. A few songs do work really well in this format. I couldn't imagine Son of Lilith being played faster or differently.

Son Of Lilith, Semtex Revolution, and About Life are great songs. These three would be on an ideal Coroner mix tape. The rest are mostly above-average, except the Beatles cover. I don't get Coroner's desire to end their albums with bizarre 60's covers. All in all, I believe my rating is a fair indication of what to expect. This probably won't be anyone's favorite, but it would be a reasonable addition to a collection. If you've ever wanted a mixture of Voivod and Celtic Frost with an And Justice feel, then you'll be thrilled, and I would more generally recommend this to fans of thrash, heavy, and maybe prog metal.

What Do We Know "About Life"? Nothing! - 100%

bayern, December 21st, 2011

The Swiss masters of technical thrash concluded the decade with a great album, which was largely considered the culmination of their career; at least by those who never had the patience to wait for two more years, in order to hear the grandiosity which "Mental Vortex" turned out to be. The trio have already managed to prove themselves as true auteurs on the metal field by the end of the decade: well, they have not added a groundbreaking album of the "Into the Pandemonium" proportions into their catalogue, but at the same time they haven't humiliated themselves beyond recognition with something as degrading as "Cold Lake". The new decade was arriving with new territories to be explored. How would the three youths from Zurich be able to answer to those new demands...

"Mental Vortex" is the musical analogue to the immaculate machines which the Swiss watches have had the reputation to be all these years: the riffs click and clock with the utmost precision until the very end(including on the very individual, kind of frivolous, take on the The Beatles' "I Want You (She's So Heavy)", with not a single note played just for the sake of it. Every riff and lead have been carefully calculated, as though an invisible clockwork mechanism, which makes absolutely no mistakes, has been working behind the scenes the whole time. Well, so where is all this spontaneity with which this genre has been so proud with eversince its inception? The answer in this particular case is: nowhere. But when this perfectly constructed work has been done the Coroner way, it's anything else, but boring and soulless. On the contrary: it has been made into one of the finest albums to ever grace the metal scene in general.

The sample introduction, which is taken from the Stuart Gordon cut film "Re-Animator" (based on a Lovecraft story), may be viewed as a cliche pretty common for the genre, and probably not promising much in terms of originality. But once the clinical, sterile riffs of the opening "Divine Step (Conspectu Mortis)" start cutting, twisting and turning into the least expected directions, one would quickly realize that there is quite a "metamorphosis" witnessed here, and one which is by all means worth delving into. Before continuing, however, one should also leave all his/her illusions behind: there would be neither warm subtlety here nor any lyrical, melodic digressions which worked so well on "No More Colour", giving it another unique, but in a different way, character. With those illusions left aside, one can continue to enjoy the otherwordly technicality on the string of tracks ("Son of Lilith", "Semtex Revolution", " Sirens", "Metamorphosis") which follows, containing the definitive technical compilation of riffs on the whole scene. The compositions are encyclopaedias of puzzling riff-patterns and labyrinthine song-tructures which are utterly logical, and never get lost in a senseless display of mastery, like it has been the case on other, less cleverly "plotted", efforts.

The dynamics is so big that one would hardly notice the reduction in terms of speed, the latter handsomely provided by "Pale Sister" and "About Life", consummate technical headbangers with a unique mechanical feel, which was strange even to Meshuggah at that time; there the band's infatuation with the horror genre springs up again: the closing voice sample at the end of "About Life" has been taken from Clive Barker's "Hellraiser". So far, so perfect... Having already covered Jimmy Hendrix's "Purple Haze" on "Punishment for Decadence", the ever unpredictable trio decide to "massacre" The Beatles this time in their own way, and here comes the already mentioned cover of the Brits' ""I Want You (She's So Heavy)", which is "so heavy" indeed, that it may have tumbled everything, which has been heard previously, down on any other album; but not here. This slightly off-context track scores highly on originality thanks to the "heavy" doomy approach which the guys epitomize as a welcome shift from the very demanding, clockwork delivery served so far. And it works...

This album showed an obvious move towards a more updated, modern sound which, mixed with the still prevailing old school patterns, could only have split the fanbase into two camps: those who would embrace the new ideas whole-heartedly and follow them all the way to "Grin"; and those who would start pulling out due to their conservative views and stubborn devotion to the dying classic formulas. Neither side should be blamed for its stance, of course, but those with ears (and heart; and soul) for the innovative and the pioneering would simply keep silent in wonder before another monument of a musical genius, which literally closed the chapter of classic thrash, along with other works released the same year, by subtly (so there was something subtle here, after all...) drawing paths to be explored in the near future. The band themselves never bothered to follow them, though; instead, they branched out into a less thrashy, industrial direction with "Grin" to wrap it up, thus opening another lane for a further exploration...

So what do we know about life, folks? Exactly.

Serves the revolution in a different way - 82%

autothrall, March 22nd, 2011

After an album like No More Color, Coroner might have just pulled up their tent posts, packed in their supplies and left the rest of us stunned and wandering through the ashes of astonishment, unable to escape the grim new reality they had opened through a window of precision craftsmanship. But this was a touring band, a power trio trying to make their stamp on the world beyond the cult following they had developed. To this extent, they have gone all out with the 4th full-length, Mental Vortex, so far as to record it down in Florida at Morrisound with Tom Morris. One can certainly ascertain the difference here; it's far more controlled and 'zen'. Not to say that the band have lost their touch for a climactic escalation through Tommy Vetterli's performance, but in all this feels like a stripping down of the spiraling wonders of their previous albums.

Unfortunately, this dive in complexity is relative to a descent in overall quality, a trend that would continue into their even more minimal follow-up, Grin. Mental Vortex is still a great album, with five near legendary Coroner tracks in its eaves, but this is the first case in which I felt any of my attentions slipping. Part of this is the cover of The Beatles' "I Want You (She's So Heavy)" included as a core element of the album. They perform it effortlessly, and even manage to extract its sullen, bluesy darkness to a new height, but it simply does not concur with the band's sharper, original material. I'm also not an enormous fan of the opener, "Divine Step (Conspectu Mortis)". It creates a steady, frantic step through the punch of its discordant verses, so it's a decent enough start to the proceedings, but it's about 7 minutes without that one riff I always expect from a Coroner track to blow my mind clean out of my temple. I enjoy its mellow, spacious bridge segment for the contrast against the band's typical busiwork, but that metallic, misanthropic orgasm of guitar is nowhere to be found.

"Son of Lilith" is likewise not a favorite of mine, but there are a few pretty killer riffs hovering there that do well to build appropriate tension. As for the rest of the content, it's superb, if somewhat drier than Punishment for Decadence or No More Color due to the polish of the mix. "Semtex Revolution" alternates a flowing if simplistic speed lick with a swaggering, arching melody and some nice vocal finesse, all to a steady rock beat. "Sirens" follows at largely the same gate, with some more amazing verse vocals, and a killer breakout groove that they steadily lift the thrashing towards just before 2 minutes. "Metamorphosis" is inaugurated with some whale like squeals and smooth bass, before the choppy melodic guitars lead to a glorious, marching riff so incredibly bare boned that you have to wonder how no one had come up with it before; and "About Life" is perhaps the closest track on the album to the material of No More Color, with a superb charging note pattern in the verse. Best of all, though, is "Pale Sister" with its frenzied Vetterli cycles, some of the fastest on the album, another sweet groove in the chorus, great leads, and an unexpected but catchy breakdown after the final chorus.

Perhaps it's a symptom that the band were so busy the previous few years penning labyrinthine exercises in genius, or perhaps a conscious decision to boil the writing down to what they felt were the important, underlying musical themes. Coroner was not the only band doing so in 1991, there was a far more visible example (Metallica), but the Swiss clearly weren't deviating that far from their origins in R.I.P. That said, Mental Vortex does not have nearly so much to offer as its elder siblings. The material is sufficiently dark, riff-strewn and superior to the lion's share of thrash in the early 90s which was grinding the genre to a halt, but it half turns its back on the frenetic displays of passion that brought the band to the foreground of Europe's most promising bands. Creative. Curious. Not all that exhilarating. Sadly, there would be no turning back, as the following, more groove turned, mechanical album would prove to be the straw that broke this camel's back.

-autothrall
http://www.fromthedustreturned.com

End of an era, beginning of an idea - 98%

DoctorX, October 12th, 2008

For many great music artists, the fourth album represents something special, a defining statement or culmination of career ambitions. Led Zeppelin had their untitled fourth album, Megadeth gave us Rust in Peace, and Darkthrone unleashed the nightmare of Transylvanian Hunger upon this earth. Even the Beatles, whose early efforts could be characterized as bubblegum and pabulum, began to develop an identity and artistic vision with their fourth album. Coroner gave us something truly beautiful. Mental Vortex.

As the ‘80s rolled into the ‘90s, many thrash bands lost steam. The style fell out of favor in Europe, and mutated to a more blues-based “groove metal” variant in the States. Coroner never had a presence in the US, and so their following waned from its already modest numbers. Noise Records found itself in financial trouble, and consequently the last two Coroner albums saw limited distribution, with almost no promotion. It’s a crying shame, because Mental Vortex is an earth-shattering masterpiece.

The first three Coroner records all raced towards thrash metal’s limits of speed and complexity, seemingly reaching a limit on No More Color, an album which could also have been called “No More Breathing Room.” Realizing that there are only so many notes you can pile onto one piece of music while calling it a “song,” the band opted not to cram twelve gallons of shit into a six gallon jug. It’s a lesson latter day Dream Theater might well take to heart.

Coroner instead peeled back the layers of guitar, tweaked up the bass to fatten the texture of their riffs, and let the melodies hang by sinewy threads. The boys were moving years ahead of the game now, foreshadowing the rise of melodic death metal. Time and tempo blurred like a molten alloy. Edelmann and Vetterli were playing with fire, and you could hear them cackle with glee as the rulebook burned. Songs like Metamorphosis and Divine Step are staggering and obstinate monoliths of artistic vision. The best aspect of Mental Vortex is that if it were recorded today, no one would think it out of date.

This album is slightly controversial with thrash fans, due to its simplified sound and reduced tempos. There is a genuine perception that most thrash bands sold out in the 1990s, slowing and simplifying their sound in order to attain commercial success. Much of this is true, but Coroner do not deserve guilt by association. This band had no chance at gaining play on radio or MTV, and they knew it. Broken English was their second language, the lead singer had a skullet, and perhaps most importantly, this album still sounded distinctly like Coroner, not Metallica or Pantera. There is a slight Megadeth influence, but that leads to a more affirming conclusion: this is the sort of album that should have followed Rust in Peace

And unlike most of their contemporaries, Coroner knew enough to quit while they were ahead.