Register Forgot login?

© 2002-2015
Encyclopaedia Metallum

Best viewed
without Internet Explorer,
in 1280 x 960 resolution
or higher.

The Bielsko-Biała Experiment - 87%

Metal_Thrasher90, February 28th, 2015

Astharoth belong to the 3rd generation of old school Polish metal, successors of bands formed in the mid-80’s. They decided to play their own music by the late-80’s with Gomor, Aggressor, Armagedon and Ghost. The leaders of the national scene Kat and Turbo embraced a pure thrash sound by that time, Wolf Spider had recently released their homonym debut and Metallica had just toured in the Polish territory, so thrash metal became more popular than ever behind the Iron Curtain and Dorota & co. then knew what they wanted. Their debut Gloomy Experiments was preceded by a demo and a couple of performances in major festivals like Metal Battle and Metalmania – the group quickly grew-up and obtained a respected status among their compatriot fans and musical peers. These 9 cuts demonstrate what these young Poles were once capable of.

The influence of their Teutonic neighbors is evident on titles like “Tool Of Crime” and “Insomnia”, which present series of hammering riffs and rumbling tempos, combined with harsh vocals, accented and executed with fury and rage – yet Astharoth soon reveal predilection for complexity and alternative musical influences too. In those songs, they introduce dozens of transcendental riff variations, increasingly difficult arrangements and sudden rhythm shits you might not expect. Composition on tunes like “My Difference” or “Good Night My Dear” is quite unusual, the group is determined to achieve uninterrupted progression, add a handful of distinct structures and put all their efforts on conceiving elaborated instrumental sequences, which at times might not be totally convincing, though the group’s admirable determination and enthusiasm makes their pretentious schemes work out right surprisingly most of the time. “Obsession” for instance is an explicit technical approach, incorporating a large number of accents, meticulous fills and details, alterations on beats and keys, designing some technically superior sections, accompanied by complementary verses and choruses – for nearly 6 minutes it maintains a high level of complication and difficulty without much goofs or mediocrity, which at this level is something remarkable. Riffs ain’t simply punkish and distorted, intended to be energetic and abrasive, because these Poles include lots of melody and harmonies as well, polishing the texture of guitars considerably on “Mirror’s World” and the splendid instrumental piece “Amnesia”, discovering as well some classical music reminiscence on those exquisite licks and sophisticated phrases. So you see, Open Fire, Stos and Destroyers weren’t the only fans of baroque music in Poland back then.

These Poles obey a similar musical concept to Alastor’s, emphasizing the heterogeneity of structures and arrangements – introducing diverse sections and avoiding firmly the uniformity and repetition of lines. Both bands weren’t technically flawless or incredibly skilled, in fact some songs include some clumsy mistakes and a few slightly incoherent riff changes, direction is as well occasionally unclear but the group’s admirable passion and attitude seems to eclipse somehow those weak spots. And actually each of these tracks ain’t lacking much perspective, even though at times Astharoth design excessively pretentious patterns without possessing the necessary skills and ideas to make them work but predominantly, songs are played competently and composed with freshness and inspiration. What made these guys original, different from the rich catalog of promising 80’s Polish thrash ain’t only that willingness to create technically difficult music that required so much attention and musicianship (an objective they generally accomplish here), they made their songs unique with the addition of so much pinch-harmonics and overtones specially, along with the incorporation of neo-classical fusion guitar playing. Some of their peers also introduced those alternative elements but they accented them and made them a vital part of their methodology to define the direction and nature of their sound. In that aspect, they were more sophisticated and tolerant than their equals from Alastor, whose melodic arrangements always served as a complement to the reining sonic violence. Maybe Tatarek’s filthy, haughty tone doesn’t fit the finesse and discipline of the music but it provides that cool punkish touch of rage and arrogance (although lyrical themes are predominantly abstract).

Gloomy Experiments was unique in its own way, it might not be technically immaculate or musically diverse but it sounded different from the outrageous punkish thrash of most of their pals by the early-90’s. The group recorded their debut demo and record real quick, in a matter of few months since these musicians first gathered to rehearse together. Certainly, they were lacking experience and musicianship but no ambition or confidence. Actually, they soon moved to the Bay Area looking for greater challenges, playing with Fear Factory and Biohazard - sadly, they didn’t attract the attention of record labels and much fans there, forcing the group’s dissolution in the mid-90’s but the brilliance and talent they once displayed is preserved in this album.

"Gloomy Experiments" in Musical Artistry - 100%

bayern, July 26th, 2014

Astharoth. How exactly do we spell the name of the Prince of Hell? Is it like that? Or is it Astarott? Or Astaroth? Or Astarot? Anyway, whichever way we spell it, it’ll inevitably lead us to the gloomiest place in the underworld so expect gloomy notes coming out of the hands of those signed under that name. And, if these folks (or demons, including one beautiful demoness on guitar) vote to give a more experimental spin to their gloomy template, then one should expect things to go into a non-trodden previously direction… or thereabouts.

Poland has given its fair share to the technical metal field through the years the more renowned names belonging to the death metal side (Decapitated, Sceptic, Vedonist, Never, Redemptor, Atrophia Red Sun, etc.) those bands’ rise to prominence overshadowing the modest, but utterly essential contribution made by the thrash metal practitioners. The heavy metal pioneers Kat never ventured fully into a technical/progressive territory (“Bastard” (1992) only made timid hints at it), but their main rivals Turbo released the excellent “Epidemie” (1989) which gave a hefty technical twist to the Polish scene, a tendency immediately followed by Wolf Spider for the production of two well-executed progressive thrash records. At the same time another act, Destroyers (not quite the technical allusions made with the name), were operating on a similar plate providing another two cleverly-constructed efforts with more overt nods to the Bay-Area heritage. Then the stalwarts Dragon peaked with “Scream of Death” (1991) which was an awesome technical thrash/death metal hybrid. Very few would be those who will remember some of the best kept secrets from the European thrash metal scene: the total obscures Acrimony's "In Unknown Direction" (1992), one of the last outcries of technical genius before the genre's demise.

Astharoth remained in the deep underground and never managed to find the way out of there. Quite sad since this is by far the most talented act the Polish thrash metal scene ever produced. Even after all these years, after hundreds of listens, one is still able to find moments and nuances he/she has missed before: so multi-layered and diverse the delivery is that the listener would be scratching his/her head more than once while spending his/her time with this “gloomy” “experimental” opus…

So Astharoth play… or rather, played very complex, original technical/progressive thrash which seamlessy combined the spacey discordant landscapes of Voivod and the Norwegians Equinox with the polished "aggression" of Kreator’s “Extreme Aggression” and Necrodeath’s “Fragments of Insanity”. The opening title-track perfectly exemplifies this highly non-conventional symbiosis providing a web of ultra-technical riffs and fast blitzkrieg passages for just under 4-min, the virtuous musicianship assisted by not very audible, semi-declamatory vocals akin to later-period Mille. It also sets the model to be followed by the rest of the material at times the more direct Germanic brutalisms (“Speed of Light”, this one really tries to deserve its title with the fast-paced rhythms; the proto-death intensity of “Tool of Crime”) taking the upper hand; at others the progressive eclecticism (“Obsession”) dominating the scenery in a confident, but ultimately surreal, manner.

After the 4th composition one will start wondering what else is about to happen here which hasn’t been already done: there’s so much music present in the 1st half that the 2nd one can only be a reflection of it. And what a reflection it is: the wild shredding instrumental “Amnesia” will make you forget that there are other technical metal practitioners, apart from the “psychos” here, on the planet for about 4.5-min. “Mirror’s World” brings forward the melody which has kind of been neglected until that point, but there’s no slouching in the technical and aggressive sector this track moshing with passion near the end, a glorious abstract Voivod-ish section stealing its “crown” at the very finish. “Good Night My Dear” would be the perfect soundtrack to wishing “good night” to your dearly beloved in the small hours, this number getting a dramatic semi-balladic “colouring” on top of some maddening lead sections and vortex-like riff formulas. “Insomnia” will surely deprive you from sleeping this short piece being an exercise in classical virtuosity to an extent in the beginning before ultra-fast vitriolic guitars rudely awake you in the middle bringing the winds of death metal once again the latter again surpassed by a superb ethereal passage ala Voivod and another portion of super-stylish leads.

The closing “My Difference” begs to "differ" starting with a frolic crossover tune, and the listener may smile here seeing the band preparing for a break from this exhausting performance as a finishing touch. But that’s only a wishful thinking, fortunately: the lads start thrashing like demented just a few seconds later a more serious progressive break lying in wait near the middle, a tool which was later elaborated on the works of Depressive Age (“First Depression”, above all). So there’s no mercy shown (yes, Slayer!) anywhere, neither from the technical nor from the aggressive department… all the way till the “gloomy” end.

The band relocated to the States after that (San Francisco, to be more specific) which was a promising follow-up having in mind that area’s reputation in the consolidation of our favourite thrash. Alas, this decisive step never produced anything as distinguished: the band never reached the full-length stage again although they released a string of demos in the next few years which showed them elaborating on the spacey, surreal side of their repertoire with a very stylish delivery giving Voivod a run for their money with their more advanced, even visionary if you like, look at the future of the genre. The “extreme” aggression has gone completely which may have been a major pullback to some, but the subtle progressive thrashy/post-thrashy undercurrents flowing under these songs are just a wonder to listen to, at times elusive and ephemeral, at times more strongly accentuated. These efforts, however, never materialized into something more substantial as the band folded in the mid-90's.

So what are these musical geniuses doing right now? Well, the mainman Jarek Tatarek (vocals & guitar) is in full swing with the gothic metal formation Arcane Dimension with three full-lengths released up to this point; the delivery, though, is pretty straight-forward, without any technical flourishes. I'm sure the rest of the crew all have found their own way in pursuing the American Dream: carrying on with the "gloomy experiments" in musical mastery would hardly have put them on the path to fortune and glory. Still, a place on the thrash metal pantheon is reserved for them; another similar "gloomy experiment" would surely catapult them there.

A released 6 years ago compilation of all their demos from the 90's, aplty titled "Lost Forever World", could be a sign that their dormant genius is slowly waking up... How long it'll take for it to fully awake, one wouldn't know, but the fanbase will readily embrace another chapter from "gloomy experimental" history whenever the "lecturers" are ready to deliver it. So prepare to go back to the classrooms one of these days...

Underrated doesn't equal great - 76%

vengefulgoat, February 9th, 2013

Astharoth is one of the countless euro-thrash bands that failed to get recognition during the era of thrash metal reign, whether the cause being lack of luck in music industry, or, more often that not, lack of quality music itself. And which reason is the cause of that in case of Astharoth? Well, there's a bit of both, although upon coming across this band for the first time, it makes you wish it was only the first one.

What Astharoth definitely are not, is your another run-of-the-mill thrash metal band writing absolutely listenable, but forgettable albums with few decent songs at best. Just looking at the album cover and title suggests what style of thrash metal they play: although it's not really that gloomy as title suggests, the experimental touch is there. Astharoth play technical, sometimes a bit progressive thrash metal, comparable to bands like Coroner, Mandator, maybe Blind Illusion or their countrymen Wolf Spider, you can also hear early Voivod influence.

As mentioned, the playing of all instruments is heavily technical. While the riffs are numerous and usually good, they don't stand out as something out of ordinary for the most part, although sometimes there is something catchy in their technical nature, like beginning of Mirror's World or title track. Much bigger highlight of guitar playing on this album are solos and leads, attacking you out of nowhere multiple times during a song, showing instrumental abilities without sounding like pointless wankery. Bass is a positive surprise, it is audible in production, and the playing itself is impressive, varying its role from just supporting the guitar in the behind, to mini solos or Steve Harris-esque melodies played at the end of guitar riff, sometimes even going in the front like on song Good Night My dear. Drumming on this album is a little hit and miss, sometimes unnecessarily changing tempo or playing unadequately slow or fast to the rest of the band. At times it sounds even inspired by Ventor of Kreator, adding heaviness to the music. Overall the album doesn't sound heavier or lighter than general thrash of the era. Another hit and miss element are the vocals, and here it is more miss than hit, though they contribute to this weird atmosphere this album creates. The shouted vocal additions end up annoying and cheesy, except on track two where they are done by Litza (of Turbo fame, now quite a laughing stock in Poland's musical scene). While the vocals aren't great, sometimes the disadvantage is the music goes on too long without them, giving the impression of music going nowhere. The album has quite Voivod-ish, maybe futuristic atmosphere, while the lyrics aren't exactly matching it and focusing mainly on psychological topics, although I warn you this doesn't come close matching Time Does Not Heal lyrics, these are just average.

Overall, this is quite a good release deserving more than it got, and while not being revolutionary or excellent in any way, ends up being rewarding listen. It's a grower too, even if at the very start it leaves impression of being some true underground gem.

The MMP rerelease which is available to get comes with 8 bonus tracks, which were recorded after the band moved nowhere else than SF Bay Area. The tracks didn't make its way onto second album, which is understandable considering the band didn't achieve noticable success other than supporting few bigger metal acts, and the time of the recordings was quite bad era for thrash, 1991-1994.

Weird futu-thrash - 70%

Lane, November 3rd, 2012

In their Polish years, speed/thrash metal band Astharoth created their only album, 'Gloomy Experiments'. The title fits perfectly with the music; this is anything but your usual speed/thrash metal! Get ready for some mind-warping insanity.

Astharoth's influences came from technical thrash metal, from both sides of the Atlantic ocean. German and Bay Area vibes are abound on 'Gloomy Experiments', but Canada's cyber-thrashers Voivod also were a huge influence, which can be heard straight from the album's first riff. Compositions aren't straight, but at times very meandering. This makes the music tough to get, but there's always something so cool and interesting happening every now and then, that I stay with Astharoth and their 'Gloomy Experiments' to the last. The band can jump from German style riff (Kreator is a clear influence here) to eerie Voivod-esque melody and then to jazzy bit and after two seconds to Testament style melody. There's a lot of tempo changes, so if you can't hold on with them, don't bother with Astharoth. However, there is a chorus in most of the songs, so the variety doesn't mean there are no structures in the songs. The song quality varies, but maybe I just haven't got into some songs yet. Could be well true, so eccentric experience this is.

The band's playing isn't metronome-accurate, but it breathes and makes this something unique. If you think nowadays' honed-to-perfection productions are the best thing, you should check this one out. This has so much more life in this! Sound-wise this is good as every instrument is well audible, and rawish, unpolished. Vocals are extremely characteristic. Clean vocals, some screams and such, and at times with insanely fast pace. English pronunciation is bad, but it only adds to speciality. As with the music, also with the vocals goes the word "insane".

'Gloomy Experiments' ain't for all thrash-heads, but if you search for something with personal touch, then give this a spin. But: Give it some time, because you can't get this all with one spin, if ever. Be brave, traveller!

(origially written for ArchaicMetallurgy.com in 2006)