This here thread will serve as a collection of general guidelines and also a place for asking questions about anything related to adding unlisted bands and projects to artist pages.
As many of you will undoubtedly know already, since April 2012 it's possible to add bands not listed on the Archives to artist pages as proper, "showing up in the see-also section in lineups" entries. During the process of transferring v1 lineups such non-MA remnants were (usually) -due to this feature not existing back then- added to the trivia or bio section of the respective artists, with various levels of order, formatting and detail. This stop-gap solution should now be dealt with and the bands and projects in the notes transferred to the artists' actual band listings. (read: "moved" and then deleted)
There is a list accessible through the main page (under "Other stuff to do") containing what is probably the majority of artists with unlisted bands in their descriptions.Here's a direct link.
Beware, it's (still) huge (18000+ entries) and takes a bit to fully load. This list is not exhaustive, since it only uses certain keywords/phrases like "also plays in", "other bands" or "also active in" to compile these artists. Some pages are logically bound to fall through the cracks. Still, this list should be more than good enough for now.
Some things to keep in mind:1. Full members and regular live musicians only
The non-MA bands feature is to be used only for bands the musician is a full member of. Or at least bands for which he or she is performing as a regular live musician. Guest/session appearances do not
warrant an entry. So, for example, while Dave Grohl
performed session drums on Tenacious D's debut, they should not be added to his past bands. On the other hand, Nirvana and Foo Fighters are obviously allowed.
This should be simple enough, just don't add any appearances that would, were the band(s) on MA, only show up in the "guest/session" tab. See also
Not to despair for want of complete information, though, as there is always the trivia section to use for such appearances.2. Active/past bands & roles
Whether or not a particular non-MA project mentioned is still active or not is unfortunately a bit of information that is not always conveniently available from the notes alone. Our system of active and past bands tabs for artist makes that info seem obligatory, and of course this difference should be taken into account eventually, but, for the time being, we allow a more casual approach. To quote myself:
Attention, contributors and children of technology! Unlisted bands appearing in artists' notes ("also played with:" etc.) can be added as proper non-MA entries under "active bands" by default if it is not known/obvious whether they're active or not. This should help with clearing those. It's a kind of "until proven otherwise" approach and having such bands potentially listed incorrectly is a comparatively minor issue that will gradually be fixed later on anyway.
And remember, it's also okay to pick "unknown" as a role if it isn't specified either. Of course, nothing wrong with a little research online to fill in the gaps.
...which should be comprehensible enough. However, I cannot stress enough how welcome a little bit of "detective work" on your part is, provided you have the time and inclination. But in the end, if nothing is to be found, don't hesitate to just add it under active bands and move on. The important thing at this point is to get those bands transferred.Note: Keep in mind that the tense can't always be taken as a trustworthy indicator of active/past. "Also played with:" can just as well refer to (an) active band(s) and vice versa. If it's more explicit, like "Used to play in a thrash band in his teens.", that's okay, of course.3. Be aware of additional band info
Let's say an artist has
Also used to play in the mathcore band Heisenberg.
in his or her trivia section. Business as usual, just move that band to the band listing, but
seeing as there is useful data to be retained from this mention in the notes, leave it there as well (or feel free to reword it in a more fitting way; "Heisenberg was a mathcore band.", for instance). For this example it's the genre of the unlisted band, arguably the most frequent one. Others would be some trivia about the reason for them splitting up or how they got together, the band's location, etc... Anything worth preserving that doesn't fit into the unlisted band entry.4. External links
It's fine to add an unlisted band's Facebook/Myspace/etc... page or, even better, their official website to the artist entry. After all, we do have a special category for this now. As a rule of thumb, try to limit it to only one link per band, though.
Use this template for naming external links: "[Band name] @ [Site]"; for original homepages just use the band name.5. Country tags
Whenever an unlisted band shares its name with one or more bands in the database, a country tag should be added to the entry. As was accepted policy for listed bands in v1. Here is a list with the standard ISO codes.
(use the ones with three digits) Example: http://www.metal-archives.com/artists/Sarolf/214276Note: Naturally, there's always the possibility that the supposedly unlisted band is in fact the one showing up in the database, especially when the country is the same. New bands getting added all the time and all that. So it doesn't hurt to do a quick check before adding redundant/misleading information.
To summarise, let's try to get these unsightly trivia mentions removed and the relations neatly streamlined and nicely and readily accessible to the everyday site user, without losing relevant data in the process.