I really hate rating things because I feel a lot of people look at scores and go "Oh this has a 78% it can't be that good" and you don't really read the words of the reviewer. Generally it goes like this for me:
75+: A good album/release. Something memorable, something that will have me come back to it later in time.
50-74: Mediocre, bland, uninspired, or lacking. Some bands just have bad releases. I sometimes go back to these releases, but often I look at them and forget about them.
25-49: A bad release. Something went wrong with this. The band isn't good enough, the production was bad, maybe the guitar was out of tune.
Maybe I just think its weird sounding.
0-24: Worthless. I feel below 15% the release itself is meaningless as there really isn't much between a 14% and a 2%. Of course some may differ but to me regardless its not going to be particularly enjoyable or memorable in the slightest. Looking into it isn't necessarily even needed as it's not good.
I feel a star system is better then a 100 point scale but scores don't mean an album is good or bad, a persons opinion does.
Western NY Metal Scene Facebook page.
Controlled by Fear. Grindcore. Free EP. Just do it.