Marx wrote about the relationship of the individual and nature.

Likewise, if you make black metal about christian love you kind of missed the point and the product will not be proper black metal.

I guess you'd just get bad music out of the equation since there would be, according to how I see it, a discrepancy between the medium and what one tries to express, leading to inadequacy of the product. As I said: Until proven to me otherwise.

Of course, it couldn't be a "everyone loves each other, every human is wonderful and should be happy blabla we're all equal", but if you think that's all communism has to offer, you should sit down and actually get some education in that area.

Your argumentation reminds me of this btw:

Black metal wants to kill God but replaces him with Satan, Odin etc., not because God is oppressive but because he's perceived as pathetic compared to more ancient powers. Black metal seems really more reactionary than revolutionary to me. It stands in opposition to modernity and idealizes values of past (pre-modern). There's also an aspect of a war-like mentality which to me seems very much like the Hobbesian worldview.

It's called "discussion" and it's going to happen with every single thread you create. Learn to deal with it.

Umm, the groups who glorify holocaust etc., focusing on antihuman aspect of Third Reich/second WW rather than securing future for white people don't label themselves national socialists. Those who do, either acknowledge its vileness, try to justify it, support revisionist theories or, most often, have a mixed opinion of those three variants.

It's as "legitimate" as "Christian black metal," which is to say as legitimate as KKK reggae or pro-McDonalds neofolk.

There's lots of black metal bands that have nationalistic and post-humanist viewpoints who choose not to identify with the NS community. I can't blame them, seeing how the NS/WP/WN/WS community is generally an asylum for informants and schizoids.

The idea of left-wing black metal is laughable. It's all warmed-over grindcore made by soulless drones. It's as "legitimate" as "Christian black metal," which is to say as legitimate as KKK reggae or pro-McDonalds neofolk.

I may actually approve of your idea to a certain extent by saying this though, as most plain NSBM is just plain shit. However, if it ain't plain hitler-worshipping it can work extremly well. Just as much as black metal inspired by communism and leftist ideologies can work extremly well, but probably get's shitty once it crosses the line of being way too dull and leaving certain, important aspects of black metal culture out of consideration.

One of the aspects of communism is conformity

One of the aspects of communism is conformity

^Far left politics is often as totalitarian as far right; maybe moreso, historically speaking.

Black metal has never been homogenous. Its draws from a diverse range of viewpoints, with the common ground often being a certain extreme, black and white-ness.

I want more black metal about black metal.

I have no idea what the NSBM scene is like OP. Nor do I really care, honestly. Some of my favorite black metal bands are highly racist. Like Drudkh. At least one member is a Nazi. Burzum, too. I understand why alot of metalheads wouldn't like bands like that, but personally I don't give a shit. As long as the music doesn't soley serve as a medium to promote (those) ideas, none of which Drudkh, Taake, Burzum, or WITTR do, then what does it matter? I know this isn't on topic, but I've realized many people judge those bands based on illusions. People need to listen without cognitive bias!

I want more black metal about black metal.

I thought there was something funky about one of the Weaver brothers' political idealology. Believe I was thinking of a totally different band, lol.

I can sort of understand why you'd want to narrow a genre down to certain lyrical themes (while I don't really agree), but I can't understand why you'd want to insist that black metal is always inspired by certain themes. You simply can't know what inspired the music only by listening to it.

I want more black metal about black metal.

Because genres emerge historically to satisfy specific expressive needs, and I find that in the case of black metal the essential themes can be pinpointed relatively narrowly.

I think I've heard them described as "eco-fascists" whatever the hell that is....

I want more black metal about black metal.

edit:
False. This is one of the aspects of authoritarian bullshit, which is fundamentally antithetical to Marxism.

Communism is a utopic vision possible only after a long (and in the end, bloody) process of learning from and eliminating the failures of capitalism and, thence, socialism (another lengthy phase known as "the dictatorship of the proletariat"). I could see a communist putting the "radical" back in the radical left with the style if not the spirit of black metal. Also, communism isn't so much a revolt against rich people as against oppression and the use of capital to leverage power over citizens, who ultimately should be without submission to authority, but be equals in most (if not all) respects. Wealth is not the enemy except to the very foolish who lack the comprehension that a thriving economy is of value to everyone so long as the surplus is not hoarded. It isn't a revolutionary philosophy so much as an evolutionary one. The fact that communist movements and revolutions have been undertaken is no surprise, considering how appealing it would be to a ground-down factory worker perpetually under the heel of the bourgeoisie, but they were false communism. It is impossible, even according to the philosophy of the Dialectic, to skip steps. Capitalism has to first fail in order to even begin the transformation.

As far as the spirit versus the style of black metal, and though it is unrelated to communism whatsoever, I recently read this quality review by Nightgaunt.