Name Type Year Reviews
No Life 'til Leather Demo 1982 9 (87%)
Kill 'Em All Full-length 1983 26 (86%)
Whiplash Single 1983 2 (84%)
Jump in the Fire Single 1984 4 (67%)
Ride the Lightning Full-length 1984 28 (94%)
Creeping Death Single 1984 5 (88%)
Master of Puppets Full-length 1986 25 (84%)
Master of Puppets Single 1986  
The $5.98 EP - Garage Days Re-Revisited EP 1987 5 (90%)
Cliff 'Em All! Video 1987 4 (97%)
...and Justice for All Full-length 1988 23 (83%)
Harvester of Sorrow Single 1988 3 (87%)
Eye of the Beholder Single 1988  
One Single 1989 4 (85%)
2 of One Video 1989 1 (84%)
The Good, the Bad and the Live: The 6 1/2 Year Anniversary 12" Collection Compilation 1990  
Enter Sandman Single 1991 3 (50%)
Metallica Full-length 1991 22 (73%)
The Unforgiven Single 1991 2 (96%)
Nothing Else Matters Single 1992 2 (73%)
Live at Wembley Stadium Single 1992  
For Those About to Rock - Monsters in Moscow Split video 1992  
Wherever I May Roam Single 1992 1 (76%)
Sad but True Single 1993  
Live Shit: Binge and Purge Live album 1993 7 (89%)
One (live) Single 1994  
Until It Sleeps Video 1996  
Until It Sleeps Single 1996 2 (45%)
Load Full-length 1996 19 (60%)
Hero of the Day Single 1996 1 (94%)
Mama Said Single 1996 1 (24%)
King Nothing Single 1997 2 (91%)
The Memory Remains Single 1997 1 (75%)
ReLoad Full-length 1997 13 (58%)
Live in London - Antipodean Tour Edition Single 1998  
The Unforgiven II Single 1998  
Fuel Single 1998 2 (60%)
Turn the Page Single 1998 1 (75%)
Garage Inc. Full-length 1998 7 (72%)
Cunning Stunts Video 1998 3 (84%)
Whiskey in the Jar Single 1999 1 (80%)
Die Die My Darling Single 1999 1 (71%)
Nothing Else Matters Single 1999 1 (85%)
S&M Live album 1999 13 (65%)
S&M Video 1999 2 (41%)
No Leaf Clover Single 2000 1 (56%)
I Disappear Single 2000 5 (36%)
Classic Albums: Metallica Video 2001 4 (83%)
St. Anger Full-length 2003 24 (50%)
St. Anger Single 2003 12 (41%)
Frantic Single 2003 4 (44%)
The Unnamed Feeling EP 2004 2 (55%)
Some Kind of Monster Single 2004 3 (25%)
Vinyl Box Set Boxed set 2004  
The Videos 1989-2004 Video 2006 2 (73%)
Live Earth EP 2007 2 (23%)
The Day That Never Comes Single 2008 18 (64%)
My Apocalypse Single 2008 5 (62%)
Cyanide Single 2008 3 (38%)
The Judas Kiss Single 2008 3 (59%)
Death Magnetic Full-length 2008 25 (72%)
All Nightmare Long Single 2008 1 (90%)
Broken, Beat & Scarred Single 2009  
The Metallica Collection Boxed set 2009  
Français Pour une Nuit Video 2009 1 (85%)
Orgullo, Pasión y Gloria - Tres Noches en la Ciudad de México Video 2009 1 (85%)
Frantic / Paranoid Split 2010  
Six Feet Down Under Live album 2010 2 (58%)
The Big 4: Live from Sofia, Bulgaria Split video 2010 2 (97%)
Six Feet Down Under Part II Live album 2010  
Live at Grimey's Live album 2010 1 (65%)
The View Single 2011 5 (26%)
Lulu Full-length 2011 18 (16%)
Beyond Magnetic EP 2012 4 (70%)
The First 30 Years Single 2012  
Quebec Magnetic Video 2012  
Through the Never (Music from the Motion Picture) Live album 2013 1 (78%)
One (Awards Show Rehearsal Version) Single 2014  
Lords of Summer (First Pass Version) Single 2014 6 (57%)